Shane Todd's family remains convinced he was murdered
POSTED: 09 Jul 2013 11:41 PM
In an email to Channel NewsAsia from his mother Mary Todd on Tuesday, the family argued that the police and coroner in Singapore did not consider or investigate anything other than suicide as a possible cause of death.
SINGAPORE: The family of Dr Shane Todd remains convinced that the US researcher was murdered.
In an email to Channel NewsAsia from his mother Mary Todd on Tuesday, they argued that the police and coroner in Singapore did not consider or investigate anything other than suicide as a possible cause of death.
This comes just one day after Singapore's state coroner concluded that Dr Todd had committed suicide.
Dr Todd was found hanged in his Chinatown apartment last June.
His parents believe that he was murdered because of sensitive research during his work at Singapore's Institute of Microelectronics.
The coroner's inquiry into his death was conducted in May.
During the 10-day inquiry, police said they did not see signs of any foul play at Dr Todd's apartment.
The inquiry also heard that he had accessed suicide-related websites and had been diagnosed with depression.
The family attended the coroner's inquiry but walked out of it midway through the proceedings.
In Tuesday's email, the family said this was because they felt the outcome had been pre-determined.
- CNA/xq
- wong chee tat :)
Showing posts with label Shane Todd. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Shane Todd. Show all posts
Wednesday, July 10, 2013
Monday, July 8, 2013
Shanmugam urges FT to correct inaccuracies
Shanmugam urges FT to correct inaccuracies
By Kimberly Spykerman
POSTED: 08 Jul 2013 4:45 PM
Minister for Foreign Affairs and Law K Shanmugam on Monday said he hopes the Financial Times (FT) would do the "honourable thing" and correct the inaccuracies it set out in its first article about American researcher Shane Todd's death.
SINGAPORE: Minister for Foreign Affairs and Law K Shanmugam on Monday said he hopes the Financial Times (FT) would do the "honourable thing" and correct the inaccuracies it set out in its first article about American researcher Shane Todd's death.
This follows the State Coroner's verdict that Dr Todd had committed suicide by hanging himself.
He said that the journalist who wrote the article, Raymond Bonner, had "recycled untruths" and that he hoped FT would "set out the truth".
He said the conspiracy theory that Dr Todd had been murdered was based on "untruths", "pure imagination", and "pure fantasy", pointing specifically to three allegations put forward by Dr Todd's family.
First, that the family had found Dr Todd's hard disk drive which allegedly contained proof Dr Todd was involved in sensitive research.
The minister said this was untrue as it was the Singapore police who had handed over the hard disk to the family at a meeting which US embassy officials were present. This was also confirmed by the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI).
Second, that someone had mysteriously accessed Dr Todd's computer after he died, which suggested a conspiracy.
Mr Shanmugam said that evidence in court had shown the person who accessed the computer was the investigating officer.
Third, that the family's expert witness, Dr Edward Adelstein, had said Dr Todd was strangled with a cord or wire -- a theory which he later retracted.
The minister said: "He went on, really on a thought experiment and he said given his experience in Asia, people get killed by criminals. And therefore Dr Todd must have been killed. I think you can say this is somewhat farcical."
Mr Shanmugam pointed to evidence from four pathologists -- two from the US and two top Singaporean pathologists -- who concluded that Dr Todd had committed suicide by hanging himself.
He said: "We had 73 witness statements presented in court, 44 testified. All who wanted to give evidence were able to do so. Experts were presented, we worked with the FBI. So we've cooperated with the US officials.
"I think the world can see what we have done, and all I can say is we have acted according to the law, to get to the truth. This is what we would do in every case of unnatural death. I think the US authorities can see for themselves what we have done."
The minister also acknowledged that it was not easy for Dr Todd's family to accept that he committed suicide.
He said: "I think we can all understand if we were in the parents' shoes, you know this young man, he had a PhD, he had a bright future ahead of him, he had done well... So it's very very difficult to accept that he would have gone out there with a full and promising career ahead of him, that he would have killed himself.
"We have to make allowance for that, understand that. Nevertheless, I think one has got to come to grips with the truth, and the reality, and at some point in time, reach closure and not make allegations which are not based on facts."
Mr Shanmugam added that the family never explained how the untruths came about as they walked out of the proceedings before testifying.
In response to questions about the family calling the outcome pre-determined, Mr Shanmugam said: "There's no reason for the Attorney-General's Chambers to want any conclusion," adding that all evidence had been dealt with.
Pointing to a statement issued by the US Embassy which said that the process had been "fair and transparent", Mr Shanmugam added that US-Singapore ties would not be affected.
- CNA/jc
- wong chee tat :)
By Kimberly Spykerman
POSTED: 08 Jul 2013 4:45 PM
Minister for Foreign Affairs and Law K Shanmugam on Monday said he hopes the Financial Times (FT) would do the "honourable thing" and correct the inaccuracies it set out in its first article about American researcher Shane Todd's death.
SINGAPORE: Minister for Foreign Affairs and Law K Shanmugam on Monday said he hopes the Financial Times (FT) would do the "honourable thing" and correct the inaccuracies it set out in its first article about American researcher Shane Todd's death.
This follows the State Coroner's verdict that Dr Todd had committed suicide by hanging himself.
He said that the journalist who wrote the article, Raymond Bonner, had "recycled untruths" and that he hoped FT would "set out the truth".
He said the conspiracy theory that Dr Todd had been murdered was based on "untruths", "pure imagination", and "pure fantasy", pointing specifically to three allegations put forward by Dr Todd's family.
First, that the family had found Dr Todd's hard disk drive which allegedly contained proof Dr Todd was involved in sensitive research.
The minister said this was untrue as it was the Singapore police who had handed over the hard disk to the family at a meeting which US embassy officials were present. This was also confirmed by the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI).
Second, that someone had mysteriously accessed Dr Todd's computer after he died, which suggested a conspiracy.
Mr Shanmugam said that evidence in court had shown the person who accessed the computer was the investigating officer.
Third, that the family's expert witness, Dr Edward Adelstein, had said Dr Todd was strangled with a cord or wire -- a theory which he later retracted.
The minister said: "He went on, really on a thought experiment and he said given his experience in Asia, people get killed by criminals. And therefore Dr Todd must have been killed. I think you can say this is somewhat farcical."
Mr Shanmugam pointed to evidence from four pathologists -- two from the US and two top Singaporean pathologists -- who concluded that Dr Todd had committed suicide by hanging himself.
He said: "We had 73 witness statements presented in court, 44 testified. All who wanted to give evidence were able to do so. Experts were presented, we worked with the FBI. So we've cooperated with the US officials.
"I think the world can see what we have done, and all I can say is we have acted according to the law, to get to the truth. This is what we would do in every case of unnatural death. I think the US authorities can see for themselves what we have done."
The minister also acknowledged that it was not easy for Dr Todd's family to accept that he committed suicide.
He said: "I think we can all understand if we were in the parents' shoes, you know this young man, he had a PhD, he had a bright future ahead of him, he had done well... So it's very very difficult to accept that he would have gone out there with a full and promising career ahead of him, that he would have killed himself.
"We have to make allowance for that, understand that. Nevertheless, I think one has got to come to grips with the truth, and the reality, and at some point in time, reach closure and not make allegations which are not based on facts."
Mr Shanmugam added that the family never explained how the untruths came about as they walked out of the proceedings before testifying.
In response to questions about the family calling the outcome pre-determined, Mr Shanmugam said: "There's no reason for the Attorney-General's Chambers to want any conclusion," adding that all evidence had been dealt with.
Pointing to a statement issued by the US Embassy which said that the process had been "fair and transparent", Mr Shanmugam added that US-Singapore ties would not be affected.
- CNA/jc
- wong chee tat :)
Shane Todd's family to pursue case in US
Shane Todd's family to pursue case in US
By Malcolm Brown
POSTED: 08 Jul 2013 11:59 AM
Dr Shane Todd's family back in the United States is vowing to keep pursuing its position that he was murdered.
MONTANA: There is no sign that the verdict into the death of Shane Todd, the young American electrical engineer found dead in his Singapore apartment, will end the controversy surrounding the case.
On Monday, Singapore's State Coroner Chay Yuen Fatt ruled that Dr Todd committed suicide and was not murdered as his family claims.
His family back in the United States is vowing to keep pursuing its position that he was murdered.
With the grandeur of its landscape of mountains, forests, lakes and waterways, Montana is sometimes called 'Big Sky Country'. It is a very long way from Singapore where Shane Todd died over a year ago.
For his family, neither distance nor the passage of time has diminished the desire to get to the bottom of what happened.
Dr Todd’s parents Mary and Rick Todd keep memories of their son alive, even as they fight to prove their case that he was murdered.
Instead, the Todds have assembled their own evidence, some of which they have circulated in an open letter to "media outlets and elected officials".
Among the supporting documents are photographs of their son's body, including his hands, which they say show signs of a struggle.
Underlying everything the family said is their vehement rejection of official findings that Shane Todd killed himself.
Meanwhile, the Todds try to live something like a normal life.
They point to their Christian faith and the church group which meets weekly on their property as sources of enormous support.
And, as they look to the future, the couple promises further evidence to come from the contents of their son's computer, which they found backed up on an external hard drive which they brought back home.
"The rest of the story will be told because there is a lot on that computer proving what we are contending here," said Mary Todd.
The Todds intend to wage a campaign to get American public opinion on their side. Several US lawmakers have already taken up the case but the family said that the national security implications are so serious that they plan to raise them with President Barack Obama personally.
- CNA/fa
- wong chee tat :)
By Malcolm Brown
POSTED: 08 Jul 2013 11:59 AM
Dr Shane Todd's family back in the United States is vowing to keep pursuing its position that he was murdered.
MONTANA: There is no sign that the verdict into the death of Shane Todd, the young American electrical engineer found dead in his Singapore apartment, will end the controversy surrounding the case.
On Monday, Singapore's State Coroner Chay Yuen Fatt ruled that Dr Todd committed suicide and was not murdered as his family claims.
His family back in the United States is vowing to keep pursuing its position that he was murdered.
With the grandeur of its landscape of mountains, forests, lakes and waterways, Montana is sometimes called 'Big Sky Country'. It is a very long way from Singapore where Shane Todd died over a year ago.
For his family, neither distance nor the passage of time has diminished the desire to get to the bottom of what happened.
Dr Todd’s parents Mary and Rick Todd keep memories of their son alive, even as they fight to prove their case that he was murdered.
Instead, the Todds have assembled their own evidence, some of which they have circulated in an open letter to "media outlets and elected officials".
Among the supporting documents are photographs of their son's body, including his hands, which they say show signs of a struggle.
Underlying everything the family said is their vehement rejection of official findings that Shane Todd killed himself.
Meanwhile, the Todds try to live something like a normal life.
They point to their Christian faith and the church group which meets weekly on their property as sources of enormous support.
And, as they look to the future, the couple promises further evidence to come from the contents of their son's computer, which they found backed up on an external hard drive which they brought back home.
"The rest of the story will be told because there is a lot on that computer proving what we are contending here," said Mary Todd.
The Todds intend to wage a campaign to get American public opinion on their side. Several US lawmakers have already taken up the case but the family said that the national security implications are so serious that they plan to raise them with President Barack Obama personally.
- CNA/fa
- wong chee tat :)
State coroner rules Shane Todd committed suicide
State coroner rules Shane Todd committed suicide
By Kimberly Spykerman and Claire Huang
POSTED: 08 Jul 2013 9:59 AM
State Coroner Chay Yuen Fatt on Monday ruled that American researcher Shane Todd committed suicide by hanging himself and found that no foul play was involved in his death.
SINGAPORE: State Coroner Chay Yuen Fatt said he was satisfied that there was no foul play involved in American researcher Shane Todd's death.
He said that Dr Todd had, beyond reasonable doubt, committed suicide by hanging himself.
He summarised his findings in a 15-minute hearing on Monday. This follows a 10-day inquiry which began in May.
The state coroner said that overwhelming evidence showed Dr Todd had entertained suicidal ideations of increasing severity leading up to his death.
Dr Todd was found hanged in his Chinatown apartment in June 2012. His parents however believe he was murdered.
The coroner noted that Dr Todd, who worked for Singapore's Institute of Microelectronics (IME), had faced great difficulty coping with his work after transferring to a new group. He was also unhappy with certain management decisions.
These factors, probably in part or in whole, triggered a relapse of his previous history of depression, said the coroner.
Citing the testimony of psychiatrist Nelson Lee, Coroner Chay said Dr Todd did not recover from his depression.
He said: "Dr Lee's evidence, which I accepted, was that the removal of a major stressor in a patient's life would not necessarily mean that the patient would recover, let alone recover spontaneously, even if they had a loving and supportive family, because the root of depression is ultimately due to chemical imbalances. This is logically all the more so when a patient's condition is of some severity, as was in the deceased's case."
The coroner also noted that Dr Todd had possibly felt he was not recognised at work, adding that evidence is clear Dr Todd was concerned about his ability to obtain approval for his new job.
This was due to the perceived involvement in violating US security, and it was possible that Dr Todd felt his condition might impede such clearance, said the Coroner Chay.
These concerns in all likelihood caused him to feel that his deep sense of failure would follow him back to the US, the coroner added.
Coroner Chay also said that he placed greater weight on evidence given by pathologists who were put forward by the state as they had more experience and were more qualified than the family's expert witness, Dr Edward Adelstein.
The coroner said Dr Adelstein had shown himself to be an "incredible" and "unreliable" witness who gave "unsupported" evidence.
He also noted that Dr Todd was not in possession of any classified information while working at IME, and that a project which Dr Todd's parents claimed put his life in danger did not ever materialise.
This would therefore be inconsistent with the possibility of foul play in his death.
The coroner also pointed out that there was no reason to doubt the authenticity of evidence presented by the State.
He said that there was no reason for the police to lie, referring to the family's claims that the investigating officer told them there were nuts, bolts and pulleys found at the suicide scene.
Four lawyers who represented the family during the inquiry were present in court and relayed the findings to them.
They said the family would issue a media statement once they have gone through the findings.
Gloria James Civetta, the lawyer formerly representing the Todd family at the inquiry, said: "Rick is currently in Germany and Mary is in the US. Both of them have expressed that they wish to make a statement once they review the findings that we're going to be sending to them."
Coroner Chay also extended his condolences to the Todd family and said it was evident Dr Todd was from a tight-knit family and had been loved by the people in his life. He hopes the family would be able to find closure.
In a statement, the United States Embassy in Singapore said the inquiry into Dr Todd's death was "comprehensive", "fair" and "transparent".
- CNA/fa/jc
- wong chee tat :)
By Kimberly Spykerman and Claire Huang
POSTED: 08 Jul 2013 9:59 AM
State Coroner Chay Yuen Fatt on Monday ruled that American researcher Shane Todd committed suicide by hanging himself and found that no foul play was involved in his death.
SINGAPORE: State Coroner Chay Yuen Fatt said he was satisfied that there was no foul play involved in American researcher Shane Todd's death.
He said that Dr Todd had, beyond reasonable doubt, committed suicide by hanging himself.
He summarised his findings in a 15-minute hearing on Monday. This follows a 10-day inquiry which began in May.
The state coroner said that overwhelming evidence showed Dr Todd had entertained suicidal ideations of increasing severity leading up to his death.
Dr Todd was found hanged in his Chinatown apartment in June 2012. His parents however believe he was murdered.
The coroner noted that Dr Todd, who worked for Singapore's Institute of Microelectronics (IME), had faced great difficulty coping with his work after transferring to a new group. He was also unhappy with certain management decisions.
These factors, probably in part or in whole, triggered a relapse of his previous history of depression, said the coroner.
Citing the testimony of psychiatrist Nelson Lee, Coroner Chay said Dr Todd did not recover from his depression.
He said: "Dr Lee's evidence, which I accepted, was that the removal of a major stressor in a patient's life would not necessarily mean that the patient would recover, let alone recover spontaneously, even if they had a loving and supportive family, because the root of depression is ultimately due to chemical imbalances. This is logically all the more so when a patient's condition is of some severity, as was in the deceased's case."
The coroner also noted that Dr Todd had possibly felt he was not recognised at work, adding that evidence is clear Dr Todd was concerned about his ability to obtain approval for his new job.
This was due to the perceived involvement in violating US security, and it was possible that Dr Todd felt his condition might impede such clearance, said the Coroner Chay.
These concerns in all likelihood caused him to feel that his deep sense of failure would follow him back to the US, the coroner added.
Coroner Chay also said that he placed greater weight on evidence given by pathologists who were put forward by the state as they had more experience and were more qualified than the family's expert witness, Dr Edward Adelstein.
The coroner said Dr Adelstein had shown himself to be an "incredible" and "unreliable" witness who gave "unsupported" evidence.
He also noted that Dr Todd was not in possession of any classified information while working at IME, and that a project which Dr Todd's parents claimed put his life in danger did not ever materialise.
This would therefore be inconsistent with the possibility of foul play in his death.
The coroner also pointed out that there was no reason to doubt the authenticity of evidence presented by the State.
He said that there was no reason for the police to lie, referring to the family's claims that the investigating officer told them there were nuts, bolts and pulleys found at the suicide scene.
Four lawyers who represented the family during the inquiry were present in court and relayed the findings to them.
They said the family would issue a media statement once they have gone through the findings.
Gloria James Civetta, the lawyer formerly representing the Todd family at the inquiry, said: "Rick is currently in Germany and Mary is in the US. Both of them have expressed that they wish to make a statement once they review the findings that we're going to be sending to them."
Coroner Chay also extended his condolences to the Todd family and said it was evident Dr Todd was from a tight-knit family and had been loved by the people in his life. He hopes the family would be able to find closure.
In a statement, the United States Embassy in Singapore said the inquiry into Dr Todd's death was "comprehensive", "fair" and "transparent".
- CNA/fa/jc
- wong chee tat :)
Thursday, May 16, 2013
Todd's death consistent with hanging, not garrotting: pathologist
Todd's death consistent with hanging, not garrotting: pathologist
By Kimberly Spykerman
POSTED: 16 May 2013 4:22 PM
Senior consultant forensic pathologist Dr Wee Keng Poh emphasized three points to show that Dr Shane Todd's death was consistent with hanging and not garrotting which is strangulation using a cord.
SINGAPORE: A senior consultant forensic pathologist on Thursday took the stand on the fourth day of the Coroner's Inquiry into the death of American researcher Shane Todd to explain the autopsy conclusions.
Dr Wee Keng Poh, who has been practising for more than 40 years, supervised the autopsy that was performed on Dr Todd's body.
Dr Todd was found hanged in his apartment in June last year.
Dr Wee emphasized three points to show that Dr Todd's death was consistent with hanging and not garrotting which is strangulation using a cord.
Dr Todd's parents believe their son was murdered over his work at Singapore's Institute of Microelectronics but Dr Wee noted that the ligature marks around Dr Todd's neck were typical of hanging - in that they extended from below the chin towards the back of the neck in an inverted 'V' shape.
If he had been strangled, the mark would have been more horizontal and completely encircled his neck, leaving no gap.
Dr Wee also noted that at the time of the autopsy, there appeared to be no haemorrhaging or fractures inside the neck, neither were there any scratches around the neck which would have indicated a struggle to relieve strangulation.
There were no signs of external injuries to the upper limbs and hands.
Dr Wee's findings were corroborated by two independent experts whose reports have been submitted to the Court.
The Todd family had also submitted a report from an expert they consulted - Dr Edward Adelstein, a Deputy Medical Examiner.
Dr Adelstein had expressed the view that Dr Todd's death was a homicide, referring to what looked like blunt trauma to both Dr Todd's hands as evidence of a fight.
Dr Wee explained on Thursday the bruise-like discolouration to Dr Todd's hands as "postmortem lividity" in which blood pools in the dependent parts of the body due to gravity.
The Todd family then put forward more photographs taken around July 4 last year at Dr Todd's wake, which showed what appeared to be scratches around Dr Todd's neck.
Their lawyer then asked if it was possible the marks could have been there but did not show up during the autopsy.
Dr Wee reiterated his point that the marks had not been present when Dr Todd's body was examined in Singapore.
On Thursday afternoon, the psychiatrist that Dr Todd consulted last year took to the stand.
Psychiatrist Nelson Lee told the court that he had diagnosed Dr Todd with moderate major depressive disorder with a significant component of anxiety.
Dr Todd had gone for a consultation on April 4 last year and was prescribed anti-depressants.
Dr Lee said that Dr Todd had complained of symptoms such as low mood, poor sleep and energy, as well as loss of concentration.
Dr Lee noted however, that Dr Todd did not talk about, or display any suicidal tendencies or self-harm at the time of the consultation.
Dr Todd was supposed to make an appointment for a follow-up three weeks later but did not do so.
The hearing continues.
- CNA/fa
- wong chee tat :)
By Kimberly Spykerman
POSTED: 16 May 2013 4:22 PM
Senior consultant forensic pathologist Dr Wee Keng Poh emphasized three points to show that Dr Shane Todd's death was consistent with hanging and not garrotting which is strangulation using a cord.
SINGAPORE: A senior consultant forensic pathologist on Thursday took the stand on the fourth day of the Coroner's Inquiry into the death of American researcher Shane Todd to explain the autopsy conclusions.
Dr Wee Keng Poh, who has been practising for more than 40 years, supervised the autopsy that was performed on Dr Todd's body.
Dr Todd was found hanged in his apartment in June last year.
Dr Wee emphasized three points to show that Dr Todd's death was consistent with hanging and not garrotting which is strangulation using a cord.
Dr Todd's parents believe their son was murdered over his work at Singapore's Institute of Microelectronics but Dr Wee noted that the ligature marks around Dr Todd's neck were typical of hanging - in that they extended from below the chin towards the back of the neck in an inverted 'V' shape.
If he had been strangled, the mark would have been more horizontal and completely encircled his neck, leaving no gap.
Dr Wee also noted that at the time of the autopsy, there appeared to be no haemorrhaging or fractures inside the neck, neither were there any scratches around the neck which would have indicated a struggle to relieve strangulation.
There were no signs of external injuries to the upper limbs and hands.
Dr Wee's findings were corroborated by two independent experts whose reports have been submitted to the Court.
The Todd family had also submitted a report from an expert they consulted - Dr Edward Adelstein, a Deputy Medical Examiner.
Dr Adelstein had expressed the view that Dr Todd's death was a homicide, referring to what looked like blunt trauma to both Dr Todd's hands as evidence of a fight.
Dr Wee explained on Thursday the bruise-like discolouration to Dr Todd's hands as "postmortem lividity" in which blood pools in the dependent parts of the body due to gravity.
The Todd family then put forward more photographs taken around July 4 last year at Dr Todd's wake, which showed what appeared to be scratches around Dr Todd's neck.
Their lawyer then asked if it was possible the marks could have been there but did not show up during the autopsy.
Dr Wee reiterated his point that the marks had not been present when Dr Todd's body was examined in Singapore.
On Thursday afternoon, the psychiatrist that Dr Todd consulted last year took to the stand.
Psychiatrist Nelson Lee told the court that he had diagnosed Dr Todd with moderate major depressive disorder with a significant component of anxiety.
Dr Todd had gone for a consultation on April 4 last year and was prescribed anti-depressants.
Dr Lee said that Dr Todd had complained of symptoms such as low mood, poor sleep and energy, as well as loss of concentration.
Dr Lee noted however, that Dr Todd did not talk about, or display any suicidal tendencies or self-harm at the time of the consultation.
Dr Todd was supposed to make an appointment for a follow-up three weeks later but did not do so.
The hearing continues.
- CNA/fa
- wong chee tat :)
Court hears how Todd was found hanged with feet on floor
Court hears how Todd was found hanged with feet on floor
By Kimberly Spykerman
POSTED: 15 May 2013 5:15 PM
UPDATED: 15 May 2013 10:51 PM
On the third day of the coroner's inquiry into the death of American researcher Shane Todd, the court was given an explanation on how he was found hanged with his feet on the floor.
SINGAPORE: The coroner's court was given an explanation on how American researcher Shane Todd was found hanged with his feet on the floor.
This came on the third day of the coroner's inquiry into Dr Todd's death.
Ms Lim Chin-Chin of the Health Sciences Authority's Forensic Science Division gave an account of the simulation experiments that were conducted based on evidence at the death scene.
One of the simulations involved testing the stretching and relaxing of a strap when subjected to a load similar in weight to Dr Todd's body.
The strap was a replica of the one from which Dr Todd was hanged.
Ms Lim revealed that for someone of Dr Todd's height - which is 183cm - there would still be a gap of between 6.5 cm and 11.2cm if the strap did not stretch.
But when subjected to a weight of 89kg - which is Dr Todd's weight - the strap would stretch sufficiently for Dr Todd's feet to have touched the floor.
Another simulation experiment also looked at whether it was possible for Dr Todd to secure the noose around his neck and put it over the top end of the door without any assistance.
The simulation experiments also sought to demonstrate that it was possible for Dr Todd to use his feet to kick a chair that had been found about 1.5 metres from where he was hanged.
Dr Todd's parents were clearly upset after hearing Ms Lim's evidence. As the family's lawyer was about to begin his cross-examination, Dr Todd's mother interrupted to ask if the hearing could be adjourned till Thursday as she felt like she was about to throw up.
Rick Todd, father of Dr Todd, said: "The evidence that has been presented, we can't rely on. It's been moved, it hasn't been preserved. We're trying to get to the bottom of it, I don't know if we will get to the bottom of it."
Dr Todd's mother, Mary Todd, added: "We came to Singapore to find out the truth and we were told the defence and our team would work as a team to find the truth. They're not adversarial. Yet they only are looking at suicide.
"We have given them evidence from the minute we heard our son (hanged), that he could have been murdered. We've given them computer forensic evidence, we've given them physical evidence and we are very, very disappointed."
Earlier, on Wednesday morning, a computer forensics expert testified that the integrity of a laptop belonging to Dr Todd was not compromised.
Assistant Superintendent of Police Kristen Soong, who is from the Technology Crime Division, said that analysis had been done on Dr Todd's laptop to check that no viruses or malicious software had been installed.
Her report was produced by the state's lawyers after lawyers for the Todd family asked if it was possible for someone to access a laptop from a remote location and upload documents on it.
"Suicide notes" - allegedly written by Dr Todd - were found on his laptop when police officers accessed it.
The Todd family's lawyers had asked police officers on Tuesday if it was possible the suicide notes were written by someone else.
ASP Soong said checks had been done for viruses, and on the operating system and user account.
She noted that there were no traces of failed log-ins, and that if the laptop had been accessed from a remote location, traces of malicious software would have been detected.
"The laptop wasn't compromised in any way through hacking or remote access. If so, there would have been traces," she told the court.
Mr Peter Ong, one of the lawyers acting for the Todd family, produced a log from StarHub which appeared to reflect outgoing data activity from his mobile phone between 25 and 29 June 2012 - after Dr Todd died.
The state's lawyers then said they would call a StarHub witness to the stand to explain the details on the log.
They said that questions on why there was activity on Dr Todd's phone after he died should be directed to the investigating officer when he takes the stand.
Meanwhile the Attorney-General's Chambers (AGC) has responded to the Todd family's claim that the inquiry has so far focused on suicide and not homicide.
In a statement on Wednesday, the AGC said lawyers for the Todd family have yet to state their position on the matter, even though state counsel has asked them several times.
The state has also submitted all reports from the family to the court, and notes that although the family's lawyers have raised hypothetical possibilities as to what happened, no other evidence has been provided.
The AGC added that the state still welcomes information from the family regarding evidence they wish to challenge so that it can be looked into at the inquiry.
The state notes that it is prepared to provide funding for foreign witnesses that the family wish to call on to give evidence.
A pathologist consulted by the family will be giving evidence through video-link, and a computer forensic analyst, also consulted by the Todds, is expected to give evidence in court.
- CNA/ir
- wong chee tat :)
By Kimberly Spykerman
POSTED: 15 May 2013 5:15 PM
UPDATED: 15 May 2013 10:51 PM
On the third day of the coroner's inquiry into the death of American researcher Shane Todd, the court was given an explanation on how he was found hanged with his feet on the floor.
SINGAPORE: The coroner's court was given an explanation on how American researcher Shane Todd was found hanged with his feet on the floor.
This came on the third day of the coroner's inquiry into Dr Todd's death.
Ms Lim Chin-Chin of the Health Sciences Authority's Forensic Science Division gave an account of the simulation experiments that were conducted based on evidence at the death scene.
One of the simulations involved testing the stretching and relaxing of a strap when subjected to a load similar in weight to Dr Todd's body.
The strap was a replica of the one from which Dr Todd was hanged.
Ms Lim revealed that for someone of Dr Todd's height - which is 183cm - there would still be a gap of between 6.5 cm and 11.2cm if the strap did not stretch.
But when subjected to a weight of 89kg - which is Dr Todd's weight - the strap would stretch sufficiently for Dr Todd's feet to have touched the floor.
Another simulation experiment also looked at whether it was possible for Dr Todd to secure the noose around his neck and put it over the top end of the door without any assistance.
The simulation experiments also sought to demonstrate that it was possible for Dr Todd to use his feet to kick a chair that had been found about 1.5 metres from where he was hanged.
Dr Todd's parents were clearly upset after hearing Ms Lim's evidence. As the family's lawyer was about to begin his cross-examination, Dr Todd's mother interrupted to ask if the hearing could be adjourned till Thursday as she felt like she was about to throw up.
Rick Todd, father of Dr Todd, said: "The evidence that has been presented, we can't rely on. It's been moved, it hasn't been preserved. We're trying to get to the bottom of it, I don't know if we will get to the bottom of it."
Dr Todd's mother, Mary Todd, added: "We came to Singapore to find out the truth and we were told the defence and our team would work as a team to find the truth. They're not adversarial. Yet they only are looking at suicide.
"We have given them evidence from the minute we heard our son (hanged), that he could have been murdered. We've given them computer forensic evidence, we've given them physical evidence and we are very, very disappointed."
Earlier, on Wednesday morning, a computer forensics expert testified that the integrity of a laptop belonging to Dr Todd was not compromised.
Assistant Superintendent of Police Kristen Soong, who is from the Technology Crime Division, said that analysis had been done on Dr Todd's laptop to check that no viruses or malicious software had been installed.
Her report was produced by the state's lawyers after lawyers for the Todd family asked if it was possible for someone to access a laptop from a remote location and upload documents on it.
"Suicide notes" - allegedly written by Dr Todd - were found on his laptop when police officers accessed it.
The Todd family's lawyers had asked police officers on Tuesday if it was possible the suicide notes were written by someone else.
ASP Soong said checks had been done for viruses, and on the operating system and user account.
She noted that there were no traces of failed log-ins, and that if the laptop had been accessed from a remote location, traces of malicious software would have been detected.
"The laptop wasn't compromised in any way through hacking or remote access. If so, there would have been traces," she told the court.
Mr Peter Ong, one of the lawyers acting for the Todd family, produced a log from StarHub which appeared to reflect outgoing data activity from his mobile phone between 25 and 29 June 2012 - after Dr Todd died.
The state's lawyers then said they would call a StarHub witness to the stand to explain the details on the log.
They said that questions on why there was activity on Dr Todd's phone after he died should be directed to the investigating officer when he takes the stand.
Meanwhile the Attorney-General's Chambers (AGC) has responded to the Todd family's claim that the inquiry has so far focused on suicide and not homicide.
In a statement on Wednesday, the AGC said lawyers for the Todd family have yet to state their position on the matter, even though state counsel has asked them several times.
The state has also submitted all reports from the family to the court, and notes that although the family's lawyers have raised hypothetical possibilities as to what happened, no other evidence has been provided.
The AGC added that the state still welcomes information from the family regarding evidence they wish to challenge so that it can be looked into at the inquiry.
The state notes that it is prepared to provide funding for foreign witnesses that the family wish to call on to give evidence.
A pathologist consulted by the family will be giving evidence through video-link, and a computer forensic analyst, also consulted by the Todds, is expected to give evidence in court.
- CNA/ir
- wong chee tat :)
Investigator accessed Shane Todd's hard drive: computer forensics expert
Investigator accessed Shane Todd's hard drive: computer forensics expert
By Kimberly Spykerman
POSTED: 14 May 2013 11:00 PM
An investigating officer from the Singapore Police Force was the one who accessed a hard disk drive belonging to American researcher Shane Todd after he was found hanged in his apartment, the coroner's court heard on Tuesday.
SINGAPORE: An investigating officer from the Singapore Police Force was the one who accessed a hard disk drive belonging to American researcher Shane Todd after he was found hanged in his apartment.
Details of this were given by a computer forensics expert on Tuesday -- the second day of a coroner's inquiry into Dr Todd's death.
The 31-year-old was found hanged in his Singapore apartment in June last year in an apparent suicide.
The hard disk drive has been central to claims by Dr Todd's parents that their son did not take his own life.
The parents believe Dr Todd was murdered over his work for Singapore's Institute of Microelectronics.
A hard disk drive containing work files that were accessed three days after his body was found has been central to this claim.
The coroner's court heard that the files were accessed by the investigating officer in Singapore before he returned it to Dr Todd's parents.
The officer had done so to check for any suspicious information but had returned it when he found none.
Computer forensics expert Kristen Soong, who examined the disk drive, said it was last connected to the officer's computer.
She testified that when the officer opened one particular file, a temporary file was created.
This was deleted when he closed the original file.
Her findings were supported by a report from the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), which also examined the hard drive.
In court on Tuesday, lawyers for the Todd family also put forward several hypotheses that attempted to show that the 31-year-old did not take his own life.
Police officers had said they saw no signs of forced entry into the apartment, ransacking or foul play.
But the Todd family lawyers asked if it was possible Dr Todd died elsewhere and his body was moved back to his apartment, since no blood stains were found; whether the furniture in the apartment could have been moved back to its original position to give an impression that there was no struggle; and whether the suicide notes allegedly left by him could have been written by someone else. This was because the spelling of the word "Keyes" in reference to a place in Florida was spelt incorrectly in the note.
The raising of these possibilities led to a robust exchange between lawyers for the State and the Todd family. Three times, the State's lawyers asked if these possibilities were allegations or statements of fact.
The State's lawyers also asked if the evidence laid out in court was being challenged, but the Todd family's lawyers said they were not taking a position on the matter and were only enquiring about possibilities.
A handwriting expert and DNA analyst from the Health Sciences Authority also took the stand on Tuesday.
It was revealed that the handwriting on Post-It notes found in Dr Todd's bedroom matched his writings in his notebook.
One of the Post-It notes had a password written on it. When officers used the password to access Dr Todd's computer, they found the suicide notes.
It was also revealed that four unknown DNA imprints were found on the towel and strap which were wrapped around Dr Todd's neck.
- CNA/ir
- wong chee tat :)
By Kimberly Spykerman
POSTED: 14 May 2013 11:00 PM
An investigating officer from the Singapore Police Force was the one who accessed a hard disk drive belonging to American researcher Shane Todd after he was found hanged in his apartment, the coroner's court heard on Tuesday.
SINGAPORE: An investigating officer from the Singapore Police Force was the one who accessed a hard disk drive belonging to American researcher Shane Todd after he was found hanged in his apartment.
Details of this were given by a computer forensics expert on Tuesday -- the second day of a coroner's inquiry into Dr Todd's death.
The 31-year-old was found hanged in his Singapore apartment in June last year in an apparent suicide.
The hard disk drive has been central to claims by Dr Todd's parents that their son did not take his own life.
The parents believe Dr Todd was murdered over his work for Singapore's Institute of Microelectronics.
A hard disk drive containing work files that were accessed three days after his body was found has been central to this claim.
The coroner's court heard that the files were accessed by the investigating officer in Singapore before he returned it to Dr Todd's parents.
The officer had done so to check for any suspicious information but had returned it when he found none.
Computer forensics expert Kristen Soong, who examined the disk drive, said it was last connected to the officer's computer.
She testified that when the officer opened one particular file, a temporary file was created.
This was deleted when he closed the original file.
Her findings were supported by a report from the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), which also examined the hard drive.
In court on Tuesday, lawyers for the Todd family also put forward several hypotheses that attempted to show that the 31-year-old did not take his own life.
Police officers had said they saw no signs of forced entry into the apartment, ransacking or foul play.
But the Todd family lawyers asked if it was possible Dr Todd died elsewhere and his body was moved back to his apartment, since no blood stains were found; whether the furniture in the apartment could have been moved back to its original position to give an impression that there was no struggle; and whether the suicide notes allegedly left by him could have been written by someone else. This was because the spelling of the word "Keyes" in reference to a place in Florida was spelt incorrectly in the note.
The raising of these possibilities led to a robust exchange between lawyers for the State and the Todd family. Three times, the State's lawyers asked if these possibilities were allegations or statements of fact.
The State's lawyers also asked if the evidence laid out in court was being challenged, but the Todd family's lawyers said they were not taking a position on the matter and were only enquiring about possibilities.
A handwriting expert and DNA analyst from the Health Sciences Authority also took the stand on Tuesday.
It was revealed that the handwriting on Post-It notes found in Dr Todd's bedroom matched his writings in his notebook.
One of the Post-It notes had a password written on it. When officers used the password to access Dr Todd's computer, they found the suicide notes.
It was also revealed that four unknown DNA imprints were found on the towel and strap which were wrapped around Dr Todd's neck.
- CNA/ir
- wong chee tat :)
FT article on Shane Todd is "inaccurate" and "mischievous": Police
FT article on Shane Todd is "inaccurate" and "mischievous": Police
By Kimberly Spykerman
POSTED: 11 May 2013 10:05 PM
Singapore police have labelled a recent Financial Times report on American engineer Dr Shane Todd as "inaccurate", "mischievous" and "calculated to interfere with the administration of justice in Singapore".
SINGAPORE: Singapore police have labelled a recent Financial Times report on American engineer Dr Shane Todd as "inaccurate", "mischievous" and "calculated to interfere with the administration of justice in Singapore".
The article, dated May 10 and titled "Singapore inquiry prepares to open into Shane Todd's death", reported that the police gave Dr Todd's parents different versions of how he died.
Police said the paper made no attempts to confirm this with them and that the article "grossly misrepresented" its position because alleged statements exchanged between Dr Todd's parents and the police about the death were presented as facts.
According to the article, the police had told Mr and Mrs Todd that their son had drilled holes in the bathroom wall, affixed bolts and wrapped the strap through a pulley over the door.
Police said this is "highly inappropriate" and whether such statements were actually made is to be determined by the State Coroner.
More than 60 witnesses have been lined up for the Coroner's Inquiry into the death of Dr Shane Todd. However, only half that number are likely to take the stand, with the rest providing recorded statements.
His friends will be among the first on the stand when the inquiry begins on Monday. Other witnesses include the pathologist, police officers, and his parents.
Tai Wei Shyong, the senior state counsel for Dr Todd's inquiry, said: "First of all, most important is the cause of death -- the report of the forensic pathologist, what medically caused the death.
"Secondly, it is necessary to try to piece together the life of the deceased person before he died -- what was he going through, were there any events affecting him. Thirdly, were there any indications of wrong-doing or foul play. These are generic areas every coroner's case has to deal with and that's also going to be the case in this particular instance."
The 31-year-old American was found hanged in his apartment in Chinatown. His parents believe he was murdered over research he had done while working for Singapore's Institute of Microelectronics.
During the inquiry, which is public and open, they will have the chance to raise concerns relating to the case.
Mr Tai added: "The role of the state counsel is essentially to place all of the relevant evidence before the coroner so that he can make the best possible finding as to the cause of death. Our job is to make sure everything he needs to make a decision is placed before him in an orderly and structured manner.
"Because it's an inquisitorial process and not an adversarial one, we've been working quite closely with the counsel appointed by next-of-kin, Shane's parents, that any relevant evidence that they want to place before the court will be put forward."
The inquiry will stretch till end-May. After that, the state coroner will review the evidence, and independently determine the cause of Dr Todd's death.
The coroner's findings are not subject to appeal. However, the public prosecutor may direct the coroner to reopen the inquiry if it appears further investigations are necessary.
- CNA/ac
- wong chee tat :)
By Kimberly Spykerman
POSTED: 11 May 2013 10:05 PM
Singapore police have labelled a recent Financial Times report on American engineer Dr Shane Todd as "inaccurate", "mischievous" and "calculated to interfere with the administration of justice in Singapore".
SINGAPORE: Singapore police have labelled a recent Financial Times report on American engineer Dr Shane Todd as "inaccurate", "mischievous" and "calculated to interfere with the administration of justice in Singapore".
The article, dated May 10 and titled "Singapore inquiry prepares to open into Shane Todd's death", reported that the police gave Dr Todd's parents different versions of how he died.
Police said the paper made no attempts to confirm this with them and that the article "grossly misrepresented" its position because alleged statements exchanged between Dr Todd's parents and the police about the death were presented as facts.
According to the article, the police had told Mr and Mrs Todd that their son had drilled holes in the bathroom wall, affixed bolts and wrapped the strap through a pulley over the door.
Police said this is "highly inappropriate" and whether such statements were actually made is to be determined by the State Coroner.
More than 60 witnesses have been lined up for the Coroner's Inquiry into the death of Dr Shane Todd. However, only half that number are likely to take the stand, with the rest providing recorded statements.
His friends will be among the first on the stand when the inquiry begins on Monday. Other witnesses include the pathologist, police officers, and his parents.
Tai Wei Shyong, the senior state counsel for Dr Todd's inquiry, said: "First of all, most important is the cause of death -- the report of the forensic pathologist, what medically caused the death.
"Secondly, it is necessary to try to piece together the life of the deceased person before he died -- what was he going through, were there any events affecting him. Thirdly, were there any indications of wrong-doing or foul play. These are generic areas every coroner's case has to deal with and that's also going to be the case in this particular instance."
The 31-year-old American was found hanged in his apartment in Chinatown. His parents believe he was murdered over research he had done while working for Singapore's Institute of Microelectronics.
During the inquiry, which is public and open, they will have the chance to raise concerns relating to the case.
Mr Tai added: "The role of the state counsel is essentially to place all of the relevant evidence before the coroner so that he can make the best possible finding as to the cause of death. Our job is to make sure everything he needs to make a decision is placed before him in an orderly and structured manner.
"Because it's an inquisitorial process and not an adversarial one, we've been working quite closely with the counsel appointed by next-of-kin, Shane's parents, that any relevant evidence that they want to place before the court will be put forward."
The inquiry will stretch till end-May. After that, the state coroner will review the evidence, and independently determine the cause of Dr Todd's death.
The coroner's findings are not subject to appeal. However, the public prosecutor may direct the coroner to reopen the inquiry if it appears further investigations are necessary.
- CNA/ac
- wong chee tat :)
Shane Todd's laptop showed access to suicide, depression-related websites
Shane Todd's laptop showed access to suicide, depression-related websites
By Kimberly Spykerman
POSTED: 13 May 2013 9:58 PM
Internet history on American researcher Shane Todd's laptop showed that he had run searches on suicide and depression-related websites in the days before he died. This was revealed on the first day of a coroner's inquiry into his death.
SINGAPORE: Internet history on American researcher Shane Todd's laptop showed that he had run searches on suicide and depression-related websites in the days before he died. This was revealed on the first day of a coroner's inquiry into his death.
Dr Todd's body was found hanging from a black strap in front of a closed toilet door in his bedroom. According to the police, the strap had a plastic buckle attached to it which acted as a stopper -- securing it against the top end of the toilet door.
Internet history on his laptop revealed that he had accessed suicide-related websites 19 times between March and June 2012. The last one was accessed only the day before his body was found hanged in his apartment.
According to patterns of Internet activity, Dr Todd had searched different methods of committing suicide. Depression-related webpages were also accessed -- mostly in May 2012.
Senior State Counsel Tai Wei Shyong gave these details in an opening statement to the court.
Dr Todd's parents, who have flown here for the inquiry, believe their son was murdered over research he had done while working for the Singapore Institute of Microelectronics.
However, there were notes, believed to be written by Dr Todd, found on his laptop. The notes were found after the investigation officer accessed his laptop using a password written on a post-it pad.
They were for his family, girlfriend, and friends. He said he loved them and asked their forgiveness for the pain he caused them.
Dr Todd's girlfriend and friends took the stand on Monday to describe his state of mind in the months before he died. Calling him a perfectionist, they said he was unhappy and stressed about his work. They also said he had lost weight and a twitching in his hands had become more pronounced in the months leading up to his death.
Dr Todd's girlfriend Shirley Sarmiento said he told her he had suffered from depression since October 2011. He also told her he was unhappy after transferring to another department, and working on a project that he felt could get him into trouble with the American government.
The court heard earlier that Dr Todd had seen a psychiatrist while in Singapore and been prescribed anti-depressant pills.
Officers and paramedics who were first at the scene said there were no signs of forced entry or foul play when they entered Dr Todd's apartment.
However, the counsel for the Todd family questioned if it was right for them to cut the rope holding up Dr Todd's body before the forensics team arrived, saying that that could have changed material evidence at the scene.
The court however heard that it was standard procedure to bring down a body found hanging as the priority was to "save lives". The first-responders also said they remembered seeing Dr Todd's feet on the floor when they entered the room, but could not be sure if his legs were bearing his weight.
The Todd family also said they appreciated the help they had received for the inquiry.
Rick Todd, the father of Dr Todd, said: "We really appreciate the process going on here. It's a slow process so we really appreciate the way Singapore conducts its court system."
Earlier, he and his wife thanked the Singapore government for allowing them to be part of the inquest.
The inquiry continues.
- CNA/ac
- wong chee tat :)
By Kimberly Spykerman
POSTED: 13 May 2013 9:58 PM
Internet history on American researcher Shane Todd's laptop showed that he had run searches on suicide and depression-related websites in the days before he died. This was revealed on the first day of a coroner's inquiry into his death.
SINGAPORE: Internet history on American researcher Shane Todd's laptop showed that he had run searches on suicide and depression-related websites in the days before he died. This was revealed on the first day of a coroner's inquiry into his death.
Dr Todd's body was found hanging from a black strap in front of a closed toilet door in his bedroom. According to the police, the strap had a plastic buckle attached to it which acted as a stopper -- securing it against the top end of the toilet door.
Internet history on his laptop revealed that he had accessed suicide-related websites 19 times between March and June 2012. The last one was accessed only the day before his body was found hanged in his apartment.
According to patterns of Internet activity, Dr Todd had searched different methods of committing suicide. Depression-related webpages were also accessed -- mostly in May 2012.
Senior State Counsel Tai Wei Shyong gave these details in an opening statement to the court.
Dr Todd's parents, who have flown here for the inquiry, believe their son was murdered over research he had done while working for the Singapore Institute of Microelectronics.
However, there were notes, believed to be written by Dr Todd, found on his laptop. The notes were found after the investigation officer accessed his laptop using a password written on a post-it pad.
They were for his family, girlfriend, and friends. He said he loved them and asked their forgiveness for the pain he caused them.
Dr Todd's girlfriend and friends took the stand on Monday to describe his state of mind in the months before he died. Calling him a perfectionist, they said he was unhappy and stressed about his work. They also said he had lost weight and a twitching in his hands had become more pronounced in the months leading up to his death.
Dr Todd's girlfriend Shirley Sarmiento said he told her he had suffered from depression since October 2011. He also told her he was unhappy after transferring to another department, and working on a project that he felt could get him into trouble with the American government.
The court heard earlier that Dr Todd had seen a psychiatrist while in Singapore and been prescribed anti-depressant pills.
Officers and paramedics who were first at the scene said there were no signs of forced entry or foul play when they entered Dr Todd's apartment.
However, the counsel for the Todd family questioned if it was right for them to cut the rope holding up Dr Todd's body before the forensics team arrived, saying that that could have changed material evidence at the scene.
The court however heard that it was standard procedure to bring down a body found hanging as the priority was to "save lives". The first-responders also said they remembered seeing Dr Todd's feet on the floor when they entered the room, but could not be sure if his legs were bearing his weight.
The Todd family also said they appreciated the help they had received for the inquiry.
Rick Todd, the father of Dr Todd, said: "We really appreciate the process going on here. It's a slow process so we really appreciate the way Singapore conducts its court system."
Earlier, he and his wife thanked the Singapore government for allowing them to be part of the inquest.
The inquiry continues.
- CNA/ac
- wong chee tat :)
Coroner's Inquiry into American engineer's death to begin May 13
Coroner's Inquiry into American engineer's death to begin May 13
POSTED: 08 May 2013 10:30 PM
Dr Shane Todd, 31, was found hanged in his Chinatown apartment last June in an apparent suicide. His parents arrived in Singapore on Monday to prepare for the inquiry.
SINGAPORE: A Coroner's Inquiry into the death of an American engineer will begin at the Subordinate Courts on Monday.
Dr Shane Todd, 31, was found hanged in his Chinatown apartment last June in an apparent suicide.
His parents arrived in Singapore on Monday to prepare for the inquiry - which is slated to run till the end of the month.
For Mary Todd and her husband Rick, many questions remain unanswered about their son's death.
"Well, first of all, we want to recognise how Shane died, the police have never gotten off the idea of suicide," said Rick Todd.
"We have been coping well under the circumstances but it's the most incredulous, most horrendous situation any parent could go through," said Mary Todd.
Dr Todd's parents believe he was murdered over research he had done while working for Singapore's Institute of Microelectronics.
The Todd family have also raised doubts about the way investigations were carried out.
At the Coroner's Inquiry, the Todd family can question investigation findings, as well as forensic and medical reports.
After that, the State Coroner will review the evidence and independently determine the cause of Dr Todd's death.
Some 50 witnesses are expected to take the stand, and the family will be represented by a team of five lawyers led by Gloria James-Civetta.
When contacted, the Police reiterated their previous statements on the matter, that they are committed to ensuring investigations into Dr Todd's death are thorough... and that all evidence relevant to the case is made available at the inquiry.
The Attorney-General's Chambers told MediaCorp that a Coroner's Inquiry is a fact-finding process, solely dedicated to determining the cause of and circumstances surrounding a death.
"The Attorney-General's Chambers expressed our condolences to the family of Dr Todd for their loss. The Coroner's Inquiry is a fact-finding process, solely dedicated to determining the cause of and circumstances surrounding Dr Todd's death. During the inquiry, which will be public and open, Dr Todd's family will have the opportunity to raise concerns relating to the case. AGC is currently working with the legal counsel appointed by Dr Todd's family to ensure that all evidence relating to the case is presented to the Coroner in order for him to make a proper determination."
Dr Todd's parents have made the long trip to Singapore three times in less than a year. The first - to collect their son's body, the second - to meet with officials, and now on this third trip, they hope to get the answers that they've been looking for.
- CNA/de
- wong chee tat :)
POSTED: 08 May 2013 10:30 PM
Dr Shane Todd, 31, was found hanged in his Chinatown apartment last June in an apparent suicide. His parents arrived in Singapore on Monday to prepare for the inquiry.
SINGAPORE: A Coroner's Inquiry into the death of an American engineer will begin at the Subordinate Courts on Monday.
Dr Shane Todd, 31, was found hanged in his Chinatown apartment last June in an apparent suicide.
His parents arrived in Singapore on Monday to prepare for the inquiry - which is slated to run till the end of the month.
For Mary Todd and her husband Rick, many questions remain unanswered about their son's death.
"Well, first of all, we want to recognise how Shane died, the police have never gotten off the idea of suicide," said Rick Todd.
"We have been coping well under the circumstances but it's the most incredulous, most horrendous situation any parent could go through," said Mary Todd.
Dr Todd's parents believe he was murdered over research he had done while working for Singapore's Institute of Microelectronics.
The Todd family have also raised doubts about the way investigations were carried out.
At the Coroner's Inquiry, the Todd family can question investigation findings, as well as forensic and medical reports.
After that, the State Coroner will review the evidence and independently determine the cause of Dr Todd's death.
Some 50 witnesses are expected to take the stand, and the family will be represented by a team of five lawyers led by Gloria James-Civetta.
When contacted, the Police reiterated their previous statements on the matter, that they are committed to ensuring investigations into Dr Todd's death are thorough... and that all evidence relevant to the case is made available at the inquiry.
The Attorney-General's Chambers told MediaCorp that a Coroner's Inquiry is a fact-finding process, solely dedicated to determining the cause of and circumstances surrounding a death.
"The Attorney-General's Chambers expressed our condolences to the family of Dr Todd for their loss. The Coroner's Inquiry is a fact-finding process, solely dedicated to determining the cause of and circumstances surrounding Dr Todd's death. During the inquiry, which will be public and open, Dr Todd's family will have the opportunity to raise concerns relating to the case. AGC is currently working with the legal counsel appointed by Dr Todd's family to ensure that all evidence relating to the case is presented to the Coroner in order for him to make a proper determination."
Dr Todd's parents have made the long trip to Singapore three times in less than a year. The first - to collect their son's body, the second - to meet with officials, and now on this third trip, they hope to get the answers that they've been looking for.
- CNA/de
- wong chee tat :)
Labels:
2013,
engineer,
engineers,
ime,
Institute of Microelectronics,
Shane Todd,
singapore
Monday, May 13, 2013
Shane Todd's laptop showed access to suicide, depression-related websites
Shane Todd's laptop showed access to suicide, depression-related websites
By Kimberly Spykerman
POSTED: 13 May 2013 9:58 PM
SINGAPORE: Internet history on American researcher Shane Todd's laptop showed that he had run searches on suicide and depression-related websites in the days before he died. This was revealed on the first day of a coroner's inquiry into his death.
Dr Todd's body was found hanging from a black strap in front of a closed toilet door in his bedroom. According to the police, the strap had a plastic buckle attached to it which acted as a stopper -- securing it against the top end of the toilet door.
Internet history on his laptop revealed that he had accessed suicide-related websites 19 times between March and June 2012. The last one was accessed only the day before his body was found hanged in his apartment.
According to patterns of Internet activity, Dr Todd had searched different methods of committing suicide. Depression-related webpages were also accessed -- mostly in May 2012.
Senior State Counsel Tai Wei Shyong gave these details in an opening statement to the court.
Dr Todd's parents, who have flown here for the inquiry, believe their son was murdered over research he had done while working for the Singapore Institute of Microelectronics.
However, there were notes, believed to be written by Dr Todd, found on his laptop. The notes were found after the investigation officer accessed his laptop using a password written on a post-it pad.
They were for his family, girlfriend, and friends. He said he loved them and asked their forgiveness for the pain he caused them.
Dr Todd's girlfriend and friends took the stand on Monday to describe his state of mind in the months before he died. Calling him a perfectionist, they said he was unhappy and stressed about his work. They also said he had lost weight and a twitching in his hands had become more pronounced in the months leading up to his death.
Dr Todd's girlfriend Shirley Sarmiento said he told her he had suffered from depression since October 2011. He also told her he was unhappy after transferring to another department, and working on a project that he felt could get him into trouble with the American government.
The court heard earlier that Dr Todd had seen a psychiatrist while in Singapore and been prescribed anti-depressant pills.
Officers and paramedics who were first at the scene said there were no signs of forced entry or foul play when they entered Dr Todd's apartment.
However, the counsel for the Todd family questioned if it was right for them to cut the rope holding up Dr Todd's body before the forensics team arrived, saying that that could have changed material evidence at the scene.
The court however heard that it was standard procedure to bring down a body found hanging as the priority was to "save lives". The first-responders also said they remembered seeing Dr Todd's feet on the floor when they entered the room, but could not be sure if his legs were bearing his weight.
The Todd family also said they appreciated the help they had received for the inquiry.
Rick Todd, the father of Dr Todd, said: "We really appreciate the process going on here. It's a slow process so we really appreciate the way Singapore conducts its court system."
Earlier, he and his wife thanked the Singapore government for allowing them to be part of the inquest.
The inquiry continues.
- CNA/ac
- wong chee tat :)
By Kimberly Spykerman
POSTED: 13 May 2013 9:58 PM
SINGAPORE: Internet history on American researcher Shane Todd's laptop showed that he had run searches on suicide and depression-related websites in the days before he died. This was revealed on the first day of a coroner's inquiry into his death.
Dr Todd's body was found hanging from a black strap in front of a closed toilet door in his bedroom. According to the police, the strap had a plastic buckle attached to it which acted as a stopper -- securing it against the top end of the toilet door.
Internet history on his laptop revealed that he had accessed suicide-related websites 19 times between March and June 2012. The last one was accessed only the day before his body was found hanged in his apartment.
According to patterns of Internet activity, Dr Todd had searched different methods of committing suicide. Depression-related webpages were also accessed -- mostly in May 2012.
Senior State Counsel Tai Wei Shyong gave these details in an opening statement to the court.
Dr Todd's parents, who have flown here for the inquiry, believe their son was murdered over research he had done while working for the Singapore Institute of Microelectronics.
However, there were notes, believed to be written by Dr Todd, found on his laptop. The notes were found after the investigation officer accessed his laptop using a password written on a post-it pad.
They were for his family, girlfriend, and friends. He said he loved them and asked their forgiveness for the pain he caused them.
Dr Todd's girlfriend and friends took the stand on Monday to describe his state of mind in the months before he died. Calling him a perfectionist, they said he was unhappy and stressed about his work. They also said he had lost weight and a twitching in his hands had become more pronounced in the months leading up to his death.
Dr Todd's girlfriend Shirley Sarmiento said he told her he had suffered from depression since October 2011. He also told her he was unhappy after transferring to another department, and working on a project that he felt could get him into trouble with the American government.
The court heard earlier that Dr Todd had seen a psychiatrist while in Singapore and been prescribed anti-depressant pills.
Officers and paramedics who were first at the scene said there were no signs of forced entry or foul play when they entered Dr Todd's apartment.
However, the counsel for the Todd family questioned if it was right for them to cut the rope holding up Dr Todd's body before the forensics team arrived, saying that that could have changed material evidence at the scene.
The court however heard that it was standard procedure to bring down a body found hanging as the priority was to "save lives". The first-responders also said they remembered seeing Dr Todd's feet on the floor when they entered the room, but could not be sure if his legs were bearing his weight.
The Todd family also said they appreciated the help they had received for the inquiry.
Rick Todd, the father of Dr Todd, said: "We really appreciate the process going on here. It's a slow process so we really appreciate the way Singapore conducts its court system."
Earlier, he and his wife thanked the Singapore government for allowing them to be part of the inquest.
The inquiry continues.
- CNA/ac
- wong chee tat :)
Thursday, March 21, 2013
US, S'pore officials hold discussions on Shane Todd's death
US, S'pore officials hold discussions on Shane Todd's death
Posted: 21 March 2013 1523 hrs
SINGAPORE: The US embassy in Singapore said law enforcement officials from the US and Singapore held productive and forthright discussions on the case of Dr Shane Todd, an American researcher who died in Singapore last June.
They met on Monday to follow up on the visit to Washington last week by Singapore's Foreign Minister K Shanmugam, as well as his conversations on the case with Secretary of State John Kerry, Attorney General Eric Holder and Senator Max Baucus.
The embassy said on Thursday that the cooperation and information sharing at Monday's meeting are consistent with the assurances provided in Washington and in accordance with the legal frameworks of both countries.
It said it will not comment on the details of the discussions or speculate on the outcome of the investigation, as the case is ongoing and is led by Singapore law enforcement authorities.
The Singapore Police Force has said it would ensure a thorough probe into the death of Dr Todd. He was found hanged in his apartment.
His parents believe he was murdered over work he had done while employed at Singapore's Institute of Microelectronics (IME), which is part of Singapore's Agency for Science, Technology and Research.
- CNA/xq
- wong chee tat :)
Posted: 21 March 2013 1523 hrs
SINGAPORE: The US embassy in Singapore said law enforcement officials from the US and Singapore held productive and forthright discussions on the case of Dr Shane Todd, an American researcher who died in Singapore last June.
They met on Monday to follow up on the visit to Washington last week by Singapore's Foreign Minister K Shanmugam, as well as his conversations on the case with Secretary of State John Kerry, Attorney General Eric Holder and Senator Max Baucus.
The embassy said on Thursday that the cooperation and information sharing at Monday's meeting are consistent with the assurances provided in Washington and in accordance with the legal frameworks of both countries.
It said it will not comment on the details of the discussions or speculate on the outcome of the investigation, as the case is ongoing and is led by Singapore law enforcement authorities.
The Singapore Police Force has said it would ensure a thorough probe into the death of Dr Todd. He was found hanged in his apartment.
His parents believe he was murdered over work he had done while employed at Singapore's Institute of Microelectronics (IME), which is part of Singapore's Agency for Science, Technology and Research.
- CNA/xq
- wong chee tat :)
Monday, March 18, 2013
MFA disappointed at US "pressure" tactics over investigations into Shane Todd's death
MFA disappointed at US "pressure" tactics over investigations into Shane Todd's death
By Imelda Saad | Posted: 17 March 2013 1937 hrs
SINGAPORE: Singapore's Foreign Affairs Ministry has said that the issue of applying "pressure" should not arise between countries which have a "long, open and cooperative relationship with each other, based on mutual respect".
It was responding to the latest move by two US Senators to block American funding to Singapore's Institute of Microelectronics (IME).
US Senators Max Baucus' and Jon Tester have introduced an amendment to block the funding, until the US Attorney General certifies that the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) has full access to all evidence and records relevant to the death of American Shane Todd.
The Foreign Affairs Ministry said it's "deeply disappointed by the Senators' actions and statements".
It said the Senators had requested the FBI to be given "full access" to all the evidence in the investigation conducted by the Singapore Police Force (SPF) over the case, based on "the version of the facts provided by the family alone".
The ministry added the police here have so far refrained from publicising the information gathered because investigations are ongoing.
It reiterated that there will be a public Coroner's Inquiry where all the facts will be laid out to determine the cause of Mr Todd's death.
The ministry said Singapore has made every effort to be open and transparent in both its investigation and the over projects handled by the Institute of Microelectronics.
At a recent meeting between Foreign Affairs and Law Minister K Shanmugam, with Senator Baucus (in Washington DC on 12 March 2013), Mr Shanmugam had said that the Singapore police is prepared to share relevant evidence with the FBI "in accordance with the legal framework of both countries".
"The Minister reiterated this at a press conference after the meeting. The SPF has also publicly committed to take into account any information and evidence that the FBI may independently gather. The SPF will ensure that all information is comprehensively examined and scrutinized during its investigation, and have done so through foreign experts and in this case, the FBI. The SPF will continue to work with the FBI to engage the Todd family to get their co-operation and assistance for the on-going investigation," said the MFA spokesperson.
Mr Shanmugam also pointed out that IME was subject to rigorous internal audits.
The Institute of Microelectronics is also prepared to have a team from the US to conduct a process audit here.
The ministry said it will let the outcome of the investigation and Coroner's Inquiry speak for themselves.
31-year-old Shane Todd was found hanged in his Singapore apartment in what appeared to be suicide, last June.
His parents, however, believe he was murdered.
- CNA/ck
- wong chee tat :)
By Imelda Saad | Posted: 17 March 2013 1937 hrs
SINGAPORE: Singapore's Foreign Affairs Ministry has said that the issue of applying "pressure" should not arise between countries which have a "long, open and cooperative relationship with each other, based on mutual respect".
It was responding to the latest move by two US Senators to block American funding to Singapore's Institute of Microelectronics (IME).
US Senators Max Baucus' and Jon Tester have introduced an amendment to block the funding, until the US Attorney General certifies that the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) has full access to all evidence and records relevant to the death of American Shane Todd.
The Foreign Affairs Ministry said it's "deeply disappointed by the Senators' actions and statements".
It said the Senators had requested the FBI to be given "full access" to all the evidence in the investigation conducted by the Singapore Police Force (SPF) over the case, based on "the version of the facts provided by the family alone".
The ministry added the police here have so far refrained from publicising the information gathered because investigations are ongoing.
It reiterated that there will be a public Coroner's Inquiry where all the facts will be laid out to determine the cause of Mr Todd's death.
The ministry said Singapore has made every effort to be open and transparent in both its investigation and the over projects handled by the Institute of Microelectronics.
At a recent meeting between Foreign Affairs and Law Minister K Shanmugam, with Senator Baucus (in Washington DC on 12 March 2013), Mr Shanmugam had said that the Singapore police is prepared to share relevant evidence with the FBI "in accordance with the legal framework of both countries".
"The Minister reiterated this at a press conference after the meeting. The SPF has also publicly committed to take into account any information and evidence that the FBI may independently gather. The SPF will ensure that all information is comprehensively examined and scrutinized during its investigation, and have done so through foreign experts and in this case, the FBI. The SPF will continue to work with the FBI to engage the Todd family to get their co-operation and assistance for the on-going investigation," said the MFA spokesperson.
Mr Shanmugam also pointed out that IME was subject to rigorous internal audits.
The Institute of Microelectronics is also prepared to have a team from the US to conduct a process audit here.
The ministry said it will let the outcome of the investigation and Coroner's Inquiry speak for themselves.
31-year-old Shane Todd was found hanged in his Singapore apartment in what appeared to be suicide, last June.
His parents, however, believe he was murdered.
- CNA/ck
- wong chee tat :)
S'pore invites US to probe into Shane Todd case
S'pore invites US to probe into Shane Todd case
By Simon Marks | Posted: 13 March 2013 1023 hrs
SINGAPORE: Singapore's Foreign Minister K Shanmugam said authorities are "committed to getting to the bottom" of the death of an American researcher in Singapore last year.
Thirty-one-year-old Shane Todd was found hanged in his Singapore apartment last June in an apparent suicide.
However, his parents believe he was murdered.
Speaking in Washington, Mr Shanmugam said Singapore has invited the United States to audit the relationship between Todd's employer, the Institute of Microelectronics, and the Chinese telecoms giant Huawei.
Mr Shanmugam arrived on Capitol Hill within hours of touching down in the US and his first stop was a meeting with Senator Max Baucus of Montana.
Shane Todd's parents are among his constituents.
Mr Shanmugam told reporters the authorities in Singapore will get to the bottom of the young American's death.
"A death happens in Singapore, we must get to the bottom of it. And we are the kind of country where this is done in public with a public inquiry," said Mr Shanmugam.
Todd's parents suspect their son was killed in connection with his work for Singapore's Institute of Microelectronics.
They have told media organizations he was not suicidal, but was worried by a project the Institute discussed with the Chinese telecoms giant Huawei.
For that reason, Mr Shanmugam invited US officials to take a detailed look at the relationship between the two organisations.
"The institute involved, the research institute, is subject to very rigorous audit and we are very happy for a team of a US team to come down and look at the projects and it will be very clear that there was no transfer of technology."
Dr Todd's parents are demanding more. They and Senator Baucus want the FBI to be granted oversight of the Singaporean police investigation.
"We need an independent third party verification of whatever the Singaporean police are saying, whatever the report might be, and I think the US FBI can be that objective third party," said Senator Baucus.
The Singaporean authorities said the police will share evidence in the Shane Todd case with the FBI.
However, in a telephone interview, Dr Todd's father told Channel NewsAsia that isn't enough to persuade him to share a hard drive he found in his son's apartment with the Singaporean authorities.
"We need to hear that they are willing to share all of Shane's items which are both of his computers, his journal and his cellphone. There are a lot of things we have questions about. We have to have an agency that has oversight on the part of the Singapore police," said Rick Todd.
Mr Shanmugam said the family will be entitled to participate in the public inquiry into Shane Todd's death.
- CNA/fa/ac
- wong chee tat :)
By Simon Marks | Posted: 13 March 2013 1023 hrs
SINGAPORE: Singapore's Foreign Minister K Shanmugam said authorities are "committed to getting to the bottom" of the death of an American researcher in Singapore last year.
Thirty-one-year-old Shane Todd was found hanged in his Singapore apartment last June in an apparent suicide.
However, his parents believe he was murdered.
Speaking in Washington, Mr Shanmugam said Singapore has invited the United States to audit the relationship between Todd's employer, the Institute of Microelectronics, and the Chinese telecoms giant Huawei.
Mr Shanmugam arrived on Capitol Hill within hours of touching down in the US and his first stop was a meeting with Senator Max Baucus of Montana.
Shane Todd's parents are among his constituents.
Mr Shanmugam told reporters the authorities in Singapore will get to the bottom of the young American's death.
"A death happens in Singapore, we must get to the bottom of it. And we are the kind of country where this is done in public with a public inquiry," said Mr Shanmugam.
Todd's parents suspect their son was killed in connection with his work for Singapore's Institute of Microelectronics.
They have told media organizations he was not suicidal, but was worried by a project the Institute discussed with the Chinese telecoms giant Huawei.
For that reason, Mr Shanmugam invited US officials to take a detailed look at the relationship between the two organisations.
"The institute involved, the research institute, is subject to very rigorous audit and we are very happy for a team of a US team to come down and look at the projects and it will be very clear that there was no transfer of technology."
Dr Todd's parents are demanding more. They and Senator Baucus want the FBI to be granted oversight of the Singaporean police investigation.
"We need an independent third party verification of whatever the Singaporean police are saying, whatever the report might be, and I think the US FBI can be that objective third party," said Senator Baucus.
The Singaporean authorities said the police will share evidence in the Shane Todd case with the FBI.
However, in a telephone interview, Dr Todd's father told Channel NewsAsia that isn't enough to persuade him to share a hard drive he found in his son's apartment with the Singaporean authorities.
"We need to hear that they are willing to share all of Shane's items which are both of his computers, his journal and his cellphone. There are a lot of things we have questions about. We have to have an agency that has oversight on the part of the Singapore police," said Rick Todd.
Mr Shanmugam said the family will be entitled to participate in the public inquiry into Shane Todd's death.
- CNA/fa/ac
- wong chee tat :)
Police to cooperate with FBI in Shane Todd investigation
Police to cooperate with FBI in Shane Todd investigation
Posted: 12 March 2013 2018 hrs
SINGAPORE: The Singapore Police Force (SPF) and the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) will cooperate in the investigation into Shane Todd's death.
The agencies have a longstanding working relationship and have engaged in several discussions on this matter.
The SPF will take into account any information and evidence the FBI may gather independently.
SPF has asked FBI for specific assistance in respect of the case and will share with FBI evidence obtained so far in accordance with the legal framework of both countries.
Both agencies will ensure that the investigation is thorough and all available evidence relevant to the cause of, and circumstances connected with the death of Shane Todd is made available at the coroner's inquiry before the State Coroner.
The Todd family may pose relevant questions, through a counsel or by themselves, to the witnesses about the investigation findings, and the forensic and medical reports at the coroner's inquiry.
The State Coroner will review the evidence presented and determine independently the cause of and circumstances connected with Shane Todd's death.
The SPF will ensure that all information is comprehensively examined and scrutinised during the course of the investigation and continue to work with the FBI to engage the Todd family to get their co-operation and assistance with the ongoing investigation.
-CNA/ac
- wong chee tat :)
Posted: 12 March 2013 2018 hrs
SINGAPORE: The Singapore Police Force (SPF) and the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) will cooperate in the investigation into Shane Todd's death.
The agencies have a longstanding working relationship and have engaged in several discussions on this matter.
The SPF will take into account any information and evidence the FBI may gather independently.
SPF has asked FBI for specific assistance in respect of the case and will share with FBI evidence obtained so far in accordance with the legal framework of both countries.
Both agencies will ensure that the investigation is thorough and all available evidence relevant to the cause of, and circumstances connected with the death of Shane Todd is made available at the coroner's inquiry before the State Coroner.
The Todd family may pose relevant questions, through a counsel or by themselves, to the witnesses about the investigation findings, and the forensic and medical reports at the coroner's inquiry.
The State Coroner will review the evidence presented and determine independently the cause of and circumstances connected with Shane Todd's death.
The SPF will ensure that all information is comprehensively examined and scrutinised during the course of the investigation and continue to work with the FBI to engage the Todd family to get their co-operation and assistance with the ongoing investigation.
-CNA/ac
- wong chee tat :)
Police deny allegations US engineer's death not properly investigated
Police deny allegations US engineer's death not properly investigated
By Kimberly Spykerman | Posted: 17 February 2013 1117 hrs
SINGAPORE: The Singapore Police Force (SPF) said its procedures for investigating cases, in particular those involving deaths, are of high international standards.
It was responding to queries from Channel NewsAsia about the death of American electronics engineer Shane Todd.
According to a Financial Times report published on February 15, Mr Todd allegedly hanged himself in the toilet of his apartment in Chinatown last year.
His death came shortly before he was to return to the US after an 18-month stint with the Institute of Microelectronics, a research facility.
The report also raised questions about the circumstances surrounding Mr Todd's death and the way police investigations were carried out.
In addition, the report contained interviews with Mr Todd's parents who said they believe he was murdered over his work in Singapore.
They also alleged that Mr Todd's death was not properly investigated.
The police denied this.
A SPF statement late Saturday night said that all unnatural death cases are investigated thoroughly and that police work closely with the pathologist and other relevant experts.
A spokesman noted that no prior assumptions are made on the cause of death.
He added that the police have handled this case in the same way as other cases that they have looked into.
The spokesman also noted that all crime scene locations which could contain evidence are protected from any interference with what is known as "trace evidence".
The sites are secured by police for the duration required for scene examination and evidence collection.
The conditions and items found at the crime scene are carefully recorded in great detail, as well as conserved and removed for subsequent laboratory analysis.
A coroner's inquiry into Mr Todd's death is expected to take place. Police say his family will be able to question witnesses and relevant reports that are submitted.
Police urge anyone with evidence that could assist in the investigation to share the information with them.
They have also engaged and assisted Mr Todd's family since his death, and will continue to do so.
They have also kept the American Embassy and FBI informed.
- CNA/ir
- wong chee tat :)
By Kimberly Spykerman | Posted: 17 February 2013 1117 hrs
SINGAPORE: The Singapore Police Force (SPF) said its procedures for investigating cases, in particular those involving deaths, are of high international standards.
It was responding to queries from Channel NewsAsia about the death of American electronics engineer Shane Todd.
According to a Financial Times report published on February 15, Mr Todd allegedly hanged himself in the toilet of his apartment in Chinatown last year.
His death came shortly before he was to return to the US after an 18-month stint with the Institute of Microelectronics, a research facility.
The report also raised questions about the circumstances surrounding Mr Todd's death and the way police investigations were carried out.
In addition, the report contained interviews with Mr Todd's parents who said they believe he was murdered over his work in Singapore.
They also alleged that Mr Todd's death was not properly investigated.
The police denied this.
A SPF statement late Saturday night said that all unnatural death cases are investigated thoroughly and that police work closely with the pathologist and other relevant experts.
A spokesman noted that no prior assumptions are made on the cause of death.
He added that the police have handled this case in the same way as other cases that they have looked into.
The spokesman also noted that all crime scene locations which could contain evidence are protected from any interference with what is known as "trace evidence".
The sites are secured by police for the duration required for scene examination and evidence collection.
The conditions and items found at the crime scene are carefully recorded in great detail, as well as conserved and removed for subsequent laboratory analysis.
A coroner's inquiry into Mr Todd's death is expected to take place. Police say his family will be able to question witnesses and relevant reports that are submitted.
Police urge anyone with evidence that could assist in the investigation to share the information with them.
They have also engaged and assisted Mr Todd's family since his death, and will continue to do so.
They have also kept the American Embassy and FBI informed.
- CNA/ir
- wong chee tat :)
Monday, February 18, 2013
Police defend probe into Singapore death
Last updated:February 17, 2013 6:35 pm
Police defend probe into Singapore death
By Christine Spolar
The police had previously declined to answer the FT’s questions about the death of Todd, whose body was found in his apartment after his last day at work at IME. Todd’s parents, Rick and Mary Todd, believe the police have mishandled the investigation and too quickly considered his death a suicide.
The family has asked that America’s Federal Bureau of Investigation assist and be involved in investigating a possible murder. The Singapore police must request FBI assistance before the US agency can get involved.
The police on Sunday said they had kept the FBI “informed” but offered no other details. According to Singapore media, the police issued a statement saying that “no prior assumptions” had been made on the cause of death and the investigation continued.
“The police investigate all unnatural death cases thoroughly, working closely with the pathologist and other relevant experts, and no prior assumptions are made on the cause of death,” the statement reportedly said.
“Our procedures for investigating cases, particularly those involving death of persons, are strict and of high international standards. We have handled this case in the same way as other cases that police have looked into.”
It added that a coroner’s inquest would be held once the investigation was complete. The Todd family was told in an email from the police that the inquest was scheduled for March.
Todd headed a research team at IME that focused on the development of gallium nitride, a substance that can be used in both commercial and military applications, from light-emitting displays and cellular phone base stations, to radar and satellite communications.
From early 2012 Todd repeatedly told his family he was worried that he was compromising US national security with his work on a project at IME that involved a Chinese company.
After Todd’s death, the family found an external computer hard drive in his Singapore apartment with work files including one labelled “Huawei” – which appears to be a plan for a joint project between IME and Huawei Technologies, the Chinese telecoms company, for the development of gallium nitride.
The FT’s article published at the weekend explained other findings of the hard drive as well – including analysis that showed that three days after Todd’s death, someone accessed his hard drive and individual files on IME and a technical “recipe” for gallium nitride research.
The police, who removed laptops and cell phones from the apartment, apparently were unaware of the hard drive until the Todd family alerted them to its existence. The police have asked for the hard drive; the family has offered a copy if the police provide a copy of all files on laptops taken from Todd’s apartment.
IME would not comment on the Todd case, citing the police investigation. Huawei, in response to FT inquiries, said recently “We have not had any co-operation with IME with respect to [gallium nitride] so there is nothing more to add.” Veeco, a US manufacturer of equipment for use by IME, would not provide details in response to questions from the FT regarding the export of the equipment or Todd’s training and research on gallium nitride.
Additional reporting by Raymond Bonner
| SINGAPORE POLICE STATEMENT |
|
|---|---|
| ‘The
police investigate all unnatural death cases thoroughly, working
closely with the pathologist and other relevant experts, and no prior
assumptions are made on the cause of death. Our procedures for
investigating cases, particularly those involving death of persons, are
strict and of high international standards. We have handled this case in
the same way as other cases that police have looked into. ‘All crime scene locations which have the potential for recovery of evidence are handled with care and are protected from interference of any kind so as to preserve any trace evidence. The sites are secured by police for the duration required for scene examination and evidence collection. The conditions and items found at the crime scene are carefully recorded in great detail, as well as conserved and removed for subsequent laboratory analysis. ‘The Financial Times article mentioned a hard disk which was purportedly recovered by Mr and Mrs Rick Todd from their son’s residence. To ensure the investigations are as thorough as possible, we urge any person who has evidence in their possession that can assist in our investigation to share them with the police. All relevant evidence gathered by police will be tendered at the coroner’s inquiry once the investigations are completed. The coroner will independently determine the circumstances under which Mr Shane Todd came by his death taking into account the investigation findings and other evidence. During the open inquiry, the family of the deceased may question the witnesses and the relevant reports, including the pathologist report. As investigations are ongoing, it is inappropriate for the police to comment further on the case. Since the death of Mr Shane Todd, the police have engaged and assisted the family without impeding the objectivity of our investigation process. We will continue to do so. Police have also kept the American Embassy and FBI informed of this case. - wong chee tat :) |
Death in Singapore
February 15, 2013 1:10 pm
Death in Singapore
By Raymond Bonner and Christine Spolar
US electronics engineer Shane Todd was found hanging in his Singapore apartment
Shane
Todd on a dragon boat in Singapore during an outing with friends and
colleagues in 2011. This is one of a number of images featured on
Shane’s Facebook page. The photographs of Shane Todd have been provided
by the Todd family
Shane had died a week before he was to return to the US. The police said he had drilled holes into his bathroom wall, bolted in a pulley, then slipped a black strap through the pulley and wrapped it around the toilet several times. He then tethered the strap to his neck and jumped from a chair. Shane, 6ft 1in and nearly 200lb, hanged himself from the bathroom door, the autopsy report said.
So the Todds, along with two of Shane’s younger brothers, John and Dylan, were unnerved by what they didn’t see as they crossed the threshold. The front door was unlocked and there was no sign of an investigation – no crime-scene tape, no smudges from fingerprint searches. “The first thing I did was make a beeline for the bathroom,” Mrs Todd recalled. She wanted to see exactly how Shane had died – and she saw nothing that fitted the police description. The marble bathroom walls had no holes in them. Nor were there any bolts or screws. The toilet was not where the police had said.
Beyond the bathroom, Shane’s home looked like a snapshot of a man in the middle of a move. There was laundry in the dryer and dirty washing on the floor. Clean clothes were folded on the couch. Boxes were packed. Shane, in his last hours, had been trying to sell his furniture. He had written out price tags. The Todds found Shane’s airline ticket on the dining table. His laptops and mobile phone were gone – taken and kept by the Singapore police.
Police defend probe into Singapore death
Singapore police released a statement on Sunday defending their investigation into the death of Shane Todd, an American engineer who had been employed by IME, a government research agency, found hanged in his Singapore apartment in JuneBefore leaving, Mrs Todd noticed what looked like a small speaker. “Do you think the boys could use this?” she asked her husband. “Put it in the bag,” he said.
That last-minute find has altered the story of Shane Todd’s death. The card-sized plastic case was not a speaker but an external hard drive with a back-up of his computer files, including his work at IME, and a timetable and plan for a project that apparently involved IME and Huawei Technologies, the Chinese telecom giant.
The plan lays out how, from 2012 to the end of 2014, IME and Huawei would “co-develop” an amplifier device powered by gallium nitride (GaN), a semiconductor material able to withstand extreme heat and power levels well beyond silicon. GaN devices have commercial use in lighting as well as high-powered transistors for mobile phone base stations. They also have tremendous military potential, and major US defence contractors – including Northrup-Grumman and Raytheon – have pursued significant research and development in GaN for use in radar and satellite communications.
<!--.--> Security and technology experts consulted by the FT reviewed the project plan and all noted its civilian and potential military applications. Robert York, a professor of electrical and computer engineering at the University of California, Santa Barbara – a world leader in GaN research and where Shane earned a doctorate in silicon devices – said it would be “unnerving but not surprising” if Huawei were to be trying to advance its GaN technology. The high-powered amplifier has civilian use but “could be used for a number of military applications: high-powered radar, electronic warfare including signal jamming and even potentially some weapons”, Professor York added.
The colonial-era corner house in Singapore where Shane Todd lived on the first floor and where his body was found
. . .
Shane Todd was an all-American boy raised in a middle-class family who lived in California and Florida before settling in Montana. His dad was a US Navy pilot based in San Diego when Shane was born. His mother grew up in southern California and graduated from a Christian evangelical university there. Her husband, agnostic in his youth, said he “adopted Christ” early in their relationship.
Mr Todd left the Navy when Shane was three. He eventually became a commercial airline pilot. The Todds moved to Boca Raton, Florida, when Shane was 13 and the youngster – by then the oldest of four boys – acclimatised well. He was athletic – a successful wrestler – and won honours in science.
He went on to the University of Florida and developed a close group of friends. One roommate described him as “brilliant” and “highly competitive”; a rugby teammate called him a “tough son of a bitch. Not only physically … but mentally”. Shane excelled at his studies and loved a good party. “Wherever HE was, the PARTY was,” a friend wrote in a memorial. Shane also fell in love and began to question his religious upbringing. Mrs Todd said he disagreed with the idea that sex before marriage was wrong and broke from regular churchgoing.
Shane at his PhD graduation in 2010 from the University of California, Santa Barbara
In 2003, Shane graduated with honours in electrical engineering and then worked on a master’s degree. He graduated from Florida in 2005 and headed to the University of California, Santa Barbara, for his doctorate. His adviser John Bowers said Shane did groundbreaking work on high-frequency, silicon-based transmission lines. “He was very smart, motivated, determined,” Bowers said.
Shane had several job offers after graduation in 2010. He told his parents that he chose to go to Singapore because he was looking for adventure.
. . .
The Institute of Microelectronics is Singapore’s high-profile high-tech calling card. The institute is a well-regarded division within the government’s Agency for Science, Technology and Advance Research, designed to foster “world-class scientific research”. In the fast-growing city-state studded with skyscrapers, IME sits amid tree-lined streets in an area near Singapore National University.
Shane joined IME in December 2010 and was soon promoted to direct a five-man team focused on GaN devices. Sometime in 2011, according to files found on Shane’s hard drive, he began to work on what was apparently a joint project between IME and Huawei to develop a GaN amplifier.
Shane created a folder in September that year that he labelled “Huawei”. Within that was a file entitled “Schedule 1 Huawei GaN Spec 01” and this contained a “Project Plan” that outlined objectives, scope and a timetable for the proposed collaboration between IME and Huawei.
Shane was tasked with finding equipment pivotal to GaN research. He determined that Veeco, a publicly traded company in New York, manufactured the equipment they needed. Shane left the warmth of Singapore for winter in the US and was trained at the Veeco offices from January 2 to 13, 2012.
Before Shane left Singapore, IME put together a “proposal” document in November 2011 about what was expected. Shane was to “visit the Veeco facility” to train with engineers on equipment used in GaN development. Equipment purchased from Veeco as well as the technology needed by IME were mentioned. “Veeco has also stated that they will not directly transfer the best known method recipes to our tool, rather we will copy the recipe first hand during our visit.” In a tender for the equipment, also found in Shane’s files, the GaN recipe is referenced: “Can share during training but not available for technology transfer.”
Relaxing in Singapore, where he went to work for IME after graduating
In that file, IME states that the “end use will be developing recipes for growing [gallium nitride on silicon] for power electronic devices that support industrial partners in Singapore”. On the same form, IME defines the nature of the research as “commercial applications”.
Veeco declined to answer questions about its dealings with IME. “We do not have permission from IME to disclose anything,” said Wasser, vice-president for investor relations and corporate communications. In an email, she likened Veeco’s equipment to an oven used to bake a cake; the customer buys the oven and decides the recipe for its technology. Veeco provides “basic process recipes in training, not the cutting-edge recipes that our customers develop for their specific needs”, she said. The customers’ technology determines the ultimate end use, she added.
As for the IME proposal that it would be possible to “copy the recipe first hand” during the training at Veeco, Wasser said the “author of the document was confused”. “Veeco does not itself have ‘best known recipes’” for the machinery purchased by IME, she said. Customers who visit the site are not given access to any “unique recipes or formulas”, she added.
Wasser pointed out, in response to questions about Huawei, that Veeco’s equipment is already used by qualified customers in China; GaN technology is found in many consumer devices. “Veeco strives to maintain absolute compliance with all US export controls,” she said.
The situation is complicated. Any potential connection with Huawei would be problematic for Veeco and for IME because Huawei has been deemed a security risk by powerful US lawmakers. The House of Representatives intelligence committee last year warned, after an 11-month investigation, that it suspected communications equipment made by Huawei could be used for spying. It recommended the US government not use components made by Huawei, or its rival ZTE, because neither could be “trusted to be free of foreign state influence”. Huawei, in turn, denied the suspicions and decried “China bashing”. Other western countries are not so sure. Australia has banned Huawei from participating in its national broadband network. In the UK, the Intelligence and Security Committee has just finished a review of “the whole presence of Huawei” in the national infrastructure and a report is expected shortly.
Regarding the case involving Shane Todd, Huawei’s representatives declined to answer detailed questions from the FT about any project with IME or Shane Todd. In December, Scott Sykes, Huawei’s vice-president and head of international media, said: “We are not aware of any of this.” In recent weeks, Sykes responded to additional questions with the comment: “We have not had any co-operation with IME with respect to GaN so there is nothing more to add.”
The hard drive retrieved by the Todds from their son’s apartment in Singapore, containing a backup of his files from IME
Sir Colin reviewed the “Huawei” project on Shane’s hard drive for the FT and said it was a plan for a GaN-based high-electron mobility transistor – an amplifier with commercial and military applications. He said: “You can’t say it is 100 per cent for military use. There are many civilian uses.” He added: “You would be foolish not to think of military uses because there is a huge market for it.”
Sir Colin pointed out, however, that the Chinese government has a substantial interest in commercial use of GaN. China has subsidised the purchase of GaN-growth systems – from Veeco and other companies – for the production of LEDs, part of an effort to reduce China’s electricity usage, he said.
The IME trip proposal was also reviewed by Sir Colin and he told the FT that he found some of the phrasing “unusual” with regard to the suggestion that Veeco might be willing to share a technology recipe. “Normally you’d expect the recipe to be put on the machine. What the proposal says is: they won’t put it on the equipment but they will make it available.” It could then be stored on a USB or other portable drives.
Steven Huettner, who has worked on defence projects for more than 30 years in the US, much of that at Raytheon Missile Systems, also reviewed the “Huawei” project plan, and described it as “disturbing”. The project could be aimed at producing high-powered transmitters for mobile phone towers, he acknowledged, but the specifications “jump out at you”. The project “absolutely has military potential”. Huettner said, in his opinion, “an obvious use would be for high-powered radar that could enhance … military capability”.
. . .
Within weeks of returning from Veeco, Shane Todd seemed increasingly stressed. Until then, Shane “was a typical Californian. He loved life,” said one friend. But in February 2012, friends and Shane’s parents heard that he was uneasy about a work project. In his long, weekly calls through Skype to his parents, Shane said he was collaborating with a Chinese company at IME and felt that representatives asked technical questions and then spoke in Mandarin to exclude him. “I am being asked to do things with a Chinese company that make me uncomfortable,” Mrs Todd recalled him saying. “He said he felt he was being asked to compromise American security.”
Among her sons, Shane was the most private, Mrs Todd said, so she tried not to pry. But Shane complained frequently about IME, sometimes adding that he was stressed about the Chinese project. “Mom, I’m going to call you every week, and if you don’t hear from me for a week, call the American embassy,” Mrs Todd recalled him as saying. She worried that Shane was depressed – much as he had been during university – and she offered to fly to Singapore. He responded: “Mom, I’m not depressed. I’m anxious.” He said she needn’t come, she recalled.
Several times, he told his parents that he felt he was under threat because of his work with the Chinese. Mr Todd tried to talk Shane into coming home. Shane said no, he had an obligation to IME. “I remember, vividly, him saying to me, ‘I am so naive,’” Mr Todd said. “He thought he had been trained for one purpose that was above board. Then he realised he was being asked to do stuff that could harm his country’s national security.”
Mrs Todd said she didn’t ask specifics about Shane’s work. She didn’t even know the name of the Chinese company until after his death. But the stress made him come back to God, she said. “Mom, can we pray?” Shane asked in April. “If I survive this, Father, I want to live my life to serve you.”
Shane with his girlfriend on an outing to Singapore Zoo in May 2012
Still, Shirley said Shane was coping. “I’m a nurse,” she said. “I should know if somebody is suicidal.”
In late February, Shane told his parents and his girlfriend that he was quitting IME and had given 60 days’ notice. He then agreed to stay another 30 days because he was the only person trained on the Veeco equipment, his parents said.
In early April, Shane consulted Singapore psychiatrist Nelson Lee. According to a report Dr Lee wrote for the police, which was given to the Todds, Shane was referred by his doctor who noted an “increase in work stress with progressive difficulty coping”. Shane told Dr Lee that he had suffered depression years previously but that this time he was suffering more from anxiety. He told the doctor that he had experienced a loss of appetite and concentration and his sleep was disturbed. Dr Lee wrote that Shane’s “mood was generally low” and he was tearful at times. He also noted that Shane was neatly dressed, coherent and had good eye contact. He added that Shane “did not feel that life had no meaning nor were there any suicidal ideations expressed”. The psychiatrist prescribed an antidepressant. He suggested Shane come back in three weeks, which he did not do.
Shane’s time in Singapore wound down unremarkably except for some late-breaking good news. A few days before his death, Shane was offered a job by Nuvotronics, a US research firm that works with the US defence department and Nasa. David Sherrer, the company president, said Shane stood out among a dozen applicants and was offered a $105,000 pay package.
Shane was busy in his final week at IME. On Wednesday, he sent an email, inviting colleagues to “an American-style last lunch for this American guy”. He also sent an email to his mother, saying he would call soon. On Thursday he had lunch with a colleague who remembered he took three phone calls that seemed to upset him. Shane also emailed Nuvotronics with queries – could he publish research papers and file for patents, and how much holiday leave would he receive?
On Friday Shane and about three-dozen colleagues had lunch. At 5.16pm, he signed off with this email: “Thanks for helping make my time at IME a memorable experience. I wish you all the best of luck in the future. Please keep in touch.”
Shirley Sarmiento expected to hear from Shane on Friday and Saturday. When he didn’t answer her texts on Sunday, she went to his apartment. She found the door unlocked and walked into a room dark but for a light under his bedroom door.
Shirley opened the door and “got the shock of my life”. Shane was hanging from an adjoining bathroom door. His face was white, his arms dangling. He was wearing a grey T-shirt and black shorts. She pushed the body; it didn’t move. A chair, upright, stood about 5ft away. Shirley screamed and a neighbour came to her aid. The police were called and Shirley recovered enough to type a message into Shane’s Facebook page to alert his family: “This is Shane’s girlfriend. Please give me your number. I really need to call you.”
Mrs Todd awoke to see the message at 7.30 Sunday morning, at her home in Montana. “I knew instantly something was wrong,” she said. When Shirley rang, Mrs Todd heard her screaming something about a hanging. “I kept trying to figure out what the heck she was talking about,” Mrs Todd said. Then she understood. “My beloved firstborn son was dead. How could this be?”
. . .
Forty-eight sleepless hours later, the Todds walked into the Singapore police headquarters. They were met by a consular officer from the US embassy. Mr Todd asked if they should tell the police about Shane’s work, his fears for his personal safety and concerns that he had compromised US national security. The embassy officer advised the Todds to tell the police everything.
US officials would not discuss the Todd case with the FT. Instead, the embassy issued a short statement that offered “heartfelt sympathy” and referred all questions to the Singapore police. The latter did not respond to repeated questions from the FT. What follows is the Todds’ recollection of meetings with embassy and police officials. All emails referred to in this story were provided by the Todds.
Mary and Rick Todd, at their home in Marion, Montana, with Shane’s brothers (from left), Chet, Dylan and John
Mrs Todd read the notes and handed them back to the detective. “My son might have killed himself, but he did not write this,” she said with some calm.
The notes were surprising, she said later. One praised IME and its management. Another apologised for being a burden to his family. Neither sounded like Shane. One, Shane had never been a burden – “he had excelled at everything he put his mind to,” Mrs Todd said. Two, “he hated the way IME was run and the way top management treated people.” Shane’s girlfriend later said she was sure Shane’s last moments were not spent lauding IME. “He hated his job,” she said.
IME’s director, Dim-Lee Kwong, is an American who was recently awarded Singapore’s highest honour for contributions to the country’s research and development. Kwong declined to be interviewed about Shane Todd but sent this statement: “As the matter pertaining to Shane’s demise is still under police investigation, IME is unable to comment on the queries that you have raised.”
A family photo including Shane (top right) on the mantelpiece
The Todds therefore asked the mortuary to photograph Shane’s body, in the coffin, and they sent those snapshots to a pathologist recommended by a family member. Dr Edward H. Adelstein, chief of pathology at the Harry S. Truman Veterans Hospital in Missouri, examined the photos and autopsy report and wrote a review that stoked the Todds’ suspicions. Adelstein said Shane’s deeply bruised knuckles and hands should have been listed in the original autopsy. He also said the neck wounds did not look like injuries from a suicide but indicated a rapid death. He suggested a scenario far different to that outlined by the Singapore authorities: Shane fought an attacker and died by a garrotting.
The Todds sent the assessment to Detective Khaldun, who consulted the Singapore pathologist. The latter sent back a detailed dismissal of Adelstein’s review. The hands bore evidence of post-mortem pooling of blood, he wrote. Dr Adelstein had not seen the body and he did not know the difference between “findings of hanging as opposed to … garrotting”.
The Todds were left unconvinced. Then Shane’s father made an unexpected discovery. Two weeks after Shane’s funeral, he looked at the small “speaker” taken from Shane’s home and realised it was an external hard drive. He sent it to a computer analyst recommended by Mrs Todd’s brother. Ashraf Massoud works at Datachasers, a data recovery firm in Riverside, California, and he made several discoveries, which he explained to the FT.
Massoud said he could determine that on June 22 – Shane’s last day at IME – thousands of work files were transferred to the hard drive between 11am and 5.09pm. It was reasonable to think that Shane was creating a back-up from his computer, he said.
Hours later, in the middle of the night, someone went into Shane’s hard drive and accessed five folders, all labelled IME. That happened quickly, between 3.40am and 3.42am on Saturday, June 23. Since the time of Shane’s death is uncertain, Massoud could not say who looked at the IME files.
But Massoud found activity, again, on several more IME files on the night of June 27, three days after Shane’s body was found. He said someone looked at IME folders – including one labelled “Supervisor” and one labelled “Goal Setting” – between 8.38pm and 8.40pm that Wednesday. One file in particular was opened and closed but closed improperly so that a “shadow” file was created. That shadow file was then deleted by the same person. Massoud located the original file on the drive – it was a PowerPoint presentation of the “Layer structure and summary of Veeco grown HEMT wafer”. This contains the scientific formula – a specific recipe – for enhancing a GaN chip.
Massoud said his forensic findings “cannot be 100 per cent conclusive” without reviewing Shane’s computer – which the police retain. But he told the FT: “In that two-minute window, someone is perusing. Something is happening. And it’s not automated, it’s a person.”
. . .
The Todds had been sending emails to the Singapore police and the US embassy for months. Both police and embassy officials responded that the investigation was ongoing and embassy officials made clear that there had been “no determination as to whether the death of your son was a suicide or homicide”. Still, the Todds felt the police were not fully considering foul play. So, in December, the Todds flew to Singapore to make the case that their son was murdered. What follows is their version of events. Embassy officials, police and IME would not discuss the Todds’ visit with the FT.
The Todds first met embassy consul Craig Bryant, and raised their suspicions about police handling of the case. “Are you saying the Singapore police are corrupt?” Bryant asked. “That’s a serious charge.”
“Well, my son’s death is serious,” Mrs Todd replied, surprised by his tone. Mr Todd said he wasn’t accusing the police of corruption; he was accusing them of mishandling the investigation.
Two days later, the Todds had a one-and-a-half-hour meeting with US ambassador David Adelman – at one point, Mr Todd broke down in tears. Adelman, a lawyer, said he had trouble believing the police were at fault but expressed surprise when told that they had not searched for fingerprints nor taken photographs of Shane’s apartment that night.
Shane at Singapore Zoo in May 2012
An FBI spokesperson in Washington, who declined to be identified, added that the bureau cannot investigate in another country without a request from that government. “The FBI continues to follow the case of Shane Todd closely,” the spokesperson said in an email. The State Department confirmed that the Todds met with the ambassador but declined to elaborate.
The Todds’ last meeting was at the IME headquarters, and they laid out what happened in an interview with the FT immediately after. No one else involved would comment. The Todds said IME deputy director Guo-Qiang Lo was present. So was Detective Kahldun. Another police officer was there plus a lawyer, a public relations representative and a human resources liaison from IME.
“We think our son was murdered,” Mr Todd began. No one responded. He then read prepared questions from his laptop and typed in the answers.
“When did Shane first meet with Huawei?” Mr Todd asked. “When was his last meeting? Do you know the names of the attendees?”
“I can’t comment at this time,” the institute’s lawyer said. “Because of the police investigation.”
“Have the FBI contacted you about the transfer of sensitive technology to China?” “I have no information,” the lawyer said.
“Did anybody from IME forbid employees to talk about Shane?” Mr Todd asked. “You can’t police these things,” the lawyer said.
The meeting was over. The IME lawyer made a final comment that stunned the Todds. “You are not to contact IME again,” Mrs Todd recalls the lawyer saying. “There will be no further contact, no more meetings, no more emails.”
. . .
IME won’t answer questions about Shane Todd. IME has been vigilant, though, about keeping tabs on the story. A request from the FT to interview director Dim-Lee Kwong was refused in December. At the same time, IME sent an email to employees stating that an FT reporter might contact them, and that they were forbidden to talk to the media. (A recipient sent a copy to the FT.) The next day, Dr Kwong called some of Shane’s co-workers into his office and said, again, that they were not to speak to reporters, according to one employee at the meeting.
Despite the warnings, an IME employee contacted Shane’s parents. That person wrote that Shane’s death was “a tragedy” and hard to figure out. “After collecting all information available, I cannot believe it is a suicide case. Actually, no one believes it.” The person ended, saying: “I truly hope that [the] FBI can be involved and perform further investigation.”
The Todds received an email from Detective Khaldun in January. He told them that a coroner’s inquest into Shane’s death would be held in March and asked if they wanted to provide any witnesses. He also asked them for the names of Shane’s neighbours – seven months after his death, police wanted to interview them – and he requested a piece of evidence. He wanted them to hand over the hard drive they had found.
The Todds wrote back with the names of neighbours they knew. But they believe the loss of their son has national security implications and want it treated as such by Singapore and US authorities. They see Shane’s death as a warning to others – young, smart and ambitious – working in the global marketplace of commercial and defence research.
The Todds agree that Shane’s hard drive may be a critical piece of evidence in how he died and could shed fresh light on the vulnerabilities of technology safeguards. But they question how the Singapore police have so far investigated Shane’s death, so they won’t hand over the drive. They are offering, instead, to send a copy of the contents of the drive. In return, they want the Singapore police to send them a copy of all files on Shane’s laptops, which are still in police custody. And again, they are asking the Singapore authorities to invite the FBI to help investigate how their son died.
Raymond Bonner, a former correspondent for The New York Times, is the author of ‘Anatomy of Injustice’; Christine Spolar is FT Investigations Editor. Additional research by FT reporter Sally Gainsbury.
The photographs of Shane Todd published here have been provided by the Todd family.
- wong chee tat :)
Police deny allegations US engineer's death not properly investigated
Police deny allegations US engineer's death not properly investigated
By Kimberly Spykerman | Posted: 17 February 2013 1117 hrs
SINGAPORE: The Singapore Police Force (SPF) said its procedures for investigating cases, in particular those involving deaths, are of high international standards.
It was responding to queries from Channel NewsAsia about the death of American electronics engineer Shane Todd.
According to a Financial Times report published on February 15, Mr Todd allegedly hanged himself in the toilet of his apartment in Chinatown last year.
His death came shortly before he was to return to the US after an 18-month stint with the Institute of Microelectronics, a research facility.
The report also raised questions about the circumstances surrounding Mr Todd's death and the way police investigations were carried out.
In addition, the report contained interviews with Mr Todd's parents who said they believe he was murdered over his work in Singapore.
They also alleged that Mr Todd's death was not properly investigated.
The police denied this.
A SPF statement late Saturday night said that all unnatural death cases are investigated thoroughly and that police work closely with the pathologist and other relevant experts.
A spokesman noted that no prior assumptions are made on the cause of death.
He added that the police have handled this case in the same way as other cases that they have looked into.
The spokesman also noted that all crime scene locations which could contain evidence are protected from any interference with what is known as "trace evidence".
The sites are secured by police for the duration required for scene examination and evidence collection.
The conditions and items found at the crime scene are carefully recorded in great detail, as well as conserved and removed for subsequent laboratory analysis.
A coroner's inquiry into Mr Todd's death is expected to take place. Police say his family will be able to question witnesses and relevant reports that are submitted.
Police urge anyone with evidence that could assist in the investigation to share the information with them.
They have also engaged and assisted Mr Todd's family since his death, and will continue to do so.
They have also kept the American Embassy and FBI informed.
- CNA/ir
- wong chee tat :)
By Kimberly Spykerman | Posted: 17 February 2013 1117 hrs
SINGAPORE: The Singapore Police Force (SPF) said its procedures for investigating cases, in particular those involving deaths, are of high international standards.
It was responding to queries from Channel NewsAsia about the death of American electronics engineer Shane Todd.
According to a Financial Times report published on February 15, Mr Todd allegedly hanged himself in the toilet of his apartment in Chinatown last year.
His death came shortly before he was to return to the US after an 18-month stint with the Institute of Microelectronics, a research facility.
The report also raised questions about the circumstances surrounding Mr Todd's death and the way police investigations were carried out.
In addition, the report contained interviews with Mr Todd's parents who said they believe he was murdered over his work in Singapore.
They also alleged that Mr Todd's death was not properly investigated.
The police denied this.
A SPF statement late Saturday night said that all unnatural death cases are investigated thoroughly and that police work closely with the pathologist and other relevant experts.
A spokesman noted that no prior assumptions are made on the cause of death.
He added that the police have handled this case in the same way as other cases that they have looked into.
The spokesman also noted that all crime scene locations which could contain evidence are protected from any interference with what is known as "trace evidence".
The sites are secured by police for the duration required for scene examination and evidence collection.
The conditions and items found at the crime scene are carefully recorded in great detail, as well as conserved and removed for subsequent laboratory analysis.
A coroner's inquiry into Mr Todd's death is expected to take place. Police say his family will be able to question witnesses and relevant reports that are submitted.
Police urge anyone with evidence that could assist in the investigation to share the information with them.
They have also engaged and assisted Mr Todd's family since his death, and will continue to do so.
They have also kept the American Embassy and FBI informed.
- CNA/ir
- wong chee tat :)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)